Why is Star Trek: Discovery Filmed So Darkly: Exploring the Forces Behind the Dark Cinematography

Is Star Trek: Discovery's darker cinematography indicative of a faltering plot, or is there more to it? This analysis delves into the reasons behind the show's dark visuals, exploring the nature of storytelling, the competition for resources, and industry trends.

Dark Cinematography and Plotting: Are They Inseparable?

Many viewers argue that the darkness alone does not make for good storytelling. However, the truth is that lightness or darkness in a series can be a strategic narrative choice. While traditional series like The Next Generation (TNG) may be perceived as ‘lighter’ in terms of mood, this doesn’t necessarily mean that they are more plot-driven or well-structured. In fact, TNG often excelled in providing high-stakes, difficult choices and complex moral dilemmas that made the storylines highly engaging.

The Mirror Universe and High-Stakes Choices

Star Trek: Discovery frequently engages with the Mirror Universe, a realm where the federation is corrupt, honorable officers are villains, and the lines between good and evil are blurred. This setting naturally lends itself to darker themes and complex moral quandaries, which are essential to the series' narrative.

In-Depth Previews: Season 1 Compared to Season 2

Season 1 of Discovery was a masterclass in high-stakes storytelling. Episode after episode, the show delved into morally ambiguous situations that challenged the audience:

Crew members kidnapped and tortured for breeding stock The Captain’s best friend going mad and framing him for a capital crime The Captain’s other best friend going mad and trying to kill him A planetary governor killing half the colony to save the rest from famine A space battle with an implacable foe who suicides rather than surrenders Planetary populations wiped out by space monsters The Captain having to help kill the love of his life

These scenarios set the tone for a series that is unafraid to tackle difficult and mature themes. Season 2, in contrast, saw a shift in tone as the Captain, Lorca, turned out to be from the Mirror Universe. His departure marked a return to a more conventional narrative, with the returning Captain's character directions leading to a less intense, but still engaging storyline.

The Forces Shaping the Industry Today

The entertainment industry today often demands dark, gritty storytelling to capture the audience's attention. However, this trend has been driven by a mix of creative and economic factors:

The Need for Competition: With numerous series vying for viewership, a darker tone can be a way to stand out. Focusing on high-stakes, moral complexities can attract viewers who are looking for thought-provoking content. Viewership Preferences: Even as darker content garners more attention, uplifting stories tend to be more popular and long-lasting. For instance, while La La Land won critical acclaim, a film like Fly Me to Rio, set in a happier period, resonated more with audiences due to its positive ambiance. Liberal Guilt and Social Commentary: Some creators may opt for dystopian storytelling as a form of social commentary, driven by a sense of responsibility towards their audiences or society. This can often be traced back to the creators' own privilege and the moral obligation to highlight the struggles of others.

The Role of Visual Aesthetics

The darker cinematography in series like Star Trek: Discovery is also influenced by the visual aesthetics and industry standards. Filming in a constrained environment often necessitates the use of darker settings to maintain visual interest. In reality, one could argue that the Federation may have strict safety regulations, much like OSHA, but the show's scenes often depict a world where characters frequently suffer from physical and visual strain.

Conclusion

While Star Trek: Discovery’s dark cinematography is often seen as a negative, it is actually a strategic narrative choice that aligns with the show's thematic depth and the current industry trends. The series' commitment to exploring difficult moral questions and high-stakes scenarios ensures that it remains a standout in the realm of science fiction television. As the show continues to evolve, it will be interesting to see how these elements adapt and grow, further enriching the Star Trek universe and captivating its audience.