Why is Daenerys Targaryen Not Widely Appreciated for Her Actions in Essos?

Daenerys Targaryen, often referred to as Dany by her supporters, has been a polarizing figure in the narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire and the television series Game of Thrones. Her actions, particularly in Essos, have garnered a wide range of reactions, with some fans praising her while others question her motives and methods. This article explores the reasons behind the mixed reception of Daenerys Targaryen's actions in Essos, focusing on the political landscape, the impact of her policies on local populations, and the varying perspectives of those affected by her conquest.

Introduction

Among fans in both the West and the East, opinions on Daenerys Targaryen are divided. Some admire her courage and championing of the oppressed, while others criticize her for her methods and the collateral damage of her revolution. This duality is evident not only in the narrative but also in real-world discussions, where the complexities of her actions are often debated.

Fans of Game of Thrones

A recent poll among fans across the West and the East reveals that while some support Daenerys' mission to end the horrors of slavery, others are more skeptical of her methods. The political ramifications of Dany’s actions are significant, and some view her as a symbol of revolutionary change that challenges the existing order in Essos.

Views of Western Fans

In the West, the books and the show have introduced the story of Daenerys Targaryen in phases. As a result, western fans often care more about her gender and the foreign nature of her actions rather than the impact of her policies. Her efforts to free the slaves have not always resonated with them, as they focus more on her rising power and the political intrigue surrounding her.

Views of Eastern Fans

However, in the East, the impact of Daenerys Targaryen's actions is more profound. The slaves and freedmen admire her for introducing a period of liberation and hope. On the other hand, the masters and ex-masters of Essos hate her, seeing her actions as a threat to their societal order and power structures. This divide is not only ideological but also rooted in personal experiences and political alliances.

The Complexity of Her Actions

Daenerys Targaryen's actions in Essos are not simple or straightforward. Her method of breaking the slave trade involved a combination of tactical maneuvering, political negotiations, and ultimately, force. Her victories were hard won, and the aftermath has been far-reaching. Thousand of Dothraki non-combatants were brought to Meereen as part of her strategy, which has led to unpredictable social and political consequences.

Repercussions and Long-Term Impact

Meereen, a city that was once mired in slavery, is now facing the flux of societal change. The Dothraki slaves, freed by Daenerys, have settled in the city and are forming a new community. This influx has created a complex social landscape, with tensions between newcomers and long-standing residents. Additionally, the Targaryen conquest is not a new phenomenon in Essos, and many Lords are wary of her ambitions, fearing that she might bring about a significant shift in the power dynamic.

Plot and Real-World Comparisons

The plot developments in Game of Thrones often reflect the political upheavals seen in modern-day socio-political contexts. The resistance in Essos against Daenerys Targaryen's rule bears similarities to real-world struggles against oppressive regimes. Just as in our world, there are those who welcome change and those who cling to the status quo, often with justified reasons.

Conclusion

Daenerys Targaryen’s actions in Essos are a complex blend of idealism and pragmatism. Her efforts to smash the slave trade and bring about revolutionary change have had far-reaching consequences. The mixed reception among fans reflects the difficulty of supporting such a complex character. While some see her as a beacon of hope and justice, others view her as a force for disruption. The true impact of her actions may only be fully realized as the story unfolds, and as the political landscape in Essos continues to shift under her influence.