Why Unwavering Fans React Differently to Low Scores on Rotten Tomatoes

When a DC movie hits the screens, reactions can range from intense love to fierce complaints about its low scores on Rotten Tomatoes. This article explores the reasons behind such stark differences in fan engagement, focusing on critical reception and fanbase dynamics.

DC Fans and Critical Reception

When it comes to DC films, the fanbase can be incredibly passionate, often bordering on rabid. Over the years, several DC movies like Man of Steel, Batman v Superman, Suicide Squad, and Justice League have faced severe criticism from critics, yet these films remain beloved by their dedicated fanbase. This seemingly paradoxical relationship stems from a deep emotional connection to the characters and stories, which often clouds objective judgment.

Why Some Fans Disagree with Critics

For some, the anticipated reaction to a new DC film is overwhelmingly positive, shaping their expectations. This mindset often leads to disappointment when the film does not live up to these heightened expectations, resulting in vocal complaints about low scores on Rotten Tomatoes.

Classic Examples: Batman v Superman

Batman v Superman is a prime example of this phenomenon. Immediately after Warner Bros. revealed the Bat Symbol over the Superman logo at Comic-Con 2014, there was a massive outpouring of enthusiasm from the fanbase. Many fans believed that this would be one of the greatest films ever made, destined to be a cinematic masterpiece. However, when the film was released and received a dismal 28% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a group of fiercely loyal fans erupted in a state of near-agony.

These fans saw the film as a betrayal, attributing the negative reception to a supposed conspiracy involving Disney, Rotten Tomatoes, and so-called social justice warriors (SJWs). Some even fabricated the claim that Disney had an agenda to trash DC films in favor of their own Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This uproar led to a full-blown conspiracy theory, highlighting the intensity of some fan reactions.

Objectivity and Emotional Engagement

It is important to note that emotional attachment can significantly impact how fans perceive a film, even in the face of critical disapproval. For some viewers, seeing iconic characters like Superman and Batman on the big screen, especially after years of anticipation, is enough to make any criticisms irrelevant. The excitement and joy derived from these cinematic moments can overshadow critical judgment.

Take, for instance, Wonder Woman. Despite its lower than expected Rotten Tomatoes score, the film received widespread acclaim from fans. This is largely attributed to the film’s script, which, although not perfect, was generally well-received. The emotional impact of the story and the characters played a significant role in shaping the fan reception, even in the face of critical dissent.

However, there is still a core group of fans who refuse to accept any negative reviews. Even accolades from other fans and critics do not sway them. This hardcore faction believes in the inherent greatness of their beloved films, leading to a constant state of defensive uproar whenever a film does not meet their expectations.

Conclusion

The reactions to low scores on Rotten Tomatoes among DC fans highlight the complex interplay between expectation and reception. While some fans remain true to their love for the characters and stories, others struggle to accept any form of criticism. Understanding these differences can help bridge the gap between passionate fans and critical voices, fostering a more inclusive and open dialogue within the DC fan community.