Why Some TV Shows Drag On Too Long: The Case of 'Underrated' and 'Overwatched' Series

The phenomenon of a beloved TV show running well beyond its sell-by date is a frequent topic of debate among viewers and critics alike. Supernatural is a prime example, having spanned an impressive 15 seasons. However, the quality of its later episodes has raised questions about whether the show merited such longevity. This article delves into the reasons behind why certain TV shows outlive their initial popularity and explores the broader implications of this trend.

Supernatural: A Case Study in Length vs. Quality

Supernatural, initially planned for five seasons, expanded to fifteen due to its growing fan base and network support. While its initial seasons are celebrated for their compelling storytelling and character development, the final handful of episodes faltered. The inclusion of alternate universes, characters from other series, and overly generic plot devices like Mary's resurrection and Jack's return drained the show of its earlier energy.

The Paradox of Popularity and Quality

It is true that not every show that runs long does so due to its quality. Often, a show's extended run can be attributed to its broad appeal and sustained audience support. This is evident in the case of Modern Family, Empire, and This is Us, which continue to generate interest and maintain high ratings long after their initial fanbase could sustain a single series. However, some shows struggle to maintain their relevance beyond a certain point, leading to uneven and potentially disappointing seasons.

Checkerboard Examples of TV History

Comparing The Jerry Springer Show with Firefly serves as a stark reminder that the popularity and longevity of a TV show do not necessarily correlate with its overall quality or cultural impact. The Jerry Springer Show, which aired from 1991 to 2018, dominated the list of worst TV shows according to TV Guide. Despite receiving airtime for nearly three decades, it maintained a niche audience. On the other hand, Firefly, a critically acclaimed show with a passionate following, was axed after a single season due to budget constraints, leaving fans and critics alike heartbroken.

The Case of Underrated Series

Some TV series, while not universally praised, have garnered significant backlash for their prolonged run. One such example is the Netflix series mentioned, which was a detective drama that dived into gore and character conflict, yet failed to sustain a coherent narrative. The show's attempt at character development through its central detective and a young rookie proved to be ill-conceived and confusing. The relationship between the two main characters, meant to mirror the dynamic of Arthur Conan Doyle's Holmes and Watson, was disjointed and poorly executed.

Lessons from 'Overwatched' Shows

The broader lesson from series like Supernatural and the Netflix detective drama is that a show's longevity should not be a blanket endorsement of its quality. Simply because a show has a dedicated fan base or has been popular for a long time does not mean it deserves to continue for multiple seasons. Network policies and fan support often contribute to a show's extended run, but it is essential to maintain quality and avoid dragging out a story beyond its natural lifespan.

Conclusion

As viewers and critics, it is crucial to evaluate a show's longevity based on its overall quality, not just its popularity. Popular shows that outlive their welcome often risk becoming stale and formulaic. Understanding this dynamic helps us appreciate and support shows that thrive within their limited seasons, while also being vocal about those that unnecessarily prolong their run. The key lies in striking a balance between fan satisfaction and maintaining the integrity of storytelling.

Keywords

TV Show Seasons, Overwatched Shows, Underrated Series