Why Ron Was Chosen as Prefect Despite His Troublemaking Tendencies

Ron Weasley, one of the most beloved characters in the Harry Potter series, plays a significant role in the wizarding world beyond just being a best friend to Harry. Despite his troublemaking tendencies, Dumbledore selects Ron as a prefect, an action that puzzled many readers due to his role as a troublemaker. This article explores the reasoning behind Dumbledore's decision and evaluates whether Ron would have been a suitable prefect.

Reason Behind Dumbledore’s Choice

Professor Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts, had a keen eye for choosing the right candidates for the position of prefect. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, he chose Ron, and the reasons are multifaceted. Dumbledore recognizes that Harry has already taken on an unimaginable amount of responsibility during his time at Hogwarts. Choosing a prefect who is close to Harry, Ron, seems like a logical choice to ensure that Harry is not further isolated. Additionally, Dumbledore knows that Seamus Finnigan is not a reliable prefect and is initially sympathetic to the Ministry's beliefs. Therefore, placing Ron in the same dormitory with Harry serves as a buffer against Seamus's influence. Neville, while a kind and brave individual, is not deemed academically strong, and his placement might have complicated the situation.

Ron's Qualities as a Prefect

While Ron might not fit the traditional image of a prefect, his qualities make him a valuable candidate. Ron’s chess skills, as demonstrated in his championship win, are a testament to his strategic thinking. His willingness to risk his life to save Hogwarts from evil in the first year is an act of heroism. However, he lacks the academic prowess and emotional intelligence that might be necessary for a prefect who needs to navigate the complexities of Hogwarts life.

Alternative Candidates

When considering the alternatives, Dean Thomas also emerges as a suitable candidate. Dean played a crucial role in mediating during the Seamus-Finnigan incident, indicating his potential as a mediator and a prefect. Hermione Granger, while an excellent rules prefect with her unparalleled academic skills, often struggles with emotional support. Harry, despite his leadership qualities, does not have the emotional strengths to be a prefect, as his inability to cope with Hermione’s distress in Deathly Hallows demonstrates.

Consequences of Ron's Selection

Dumbledore's decision to choose Ron as a prefect, given his troublemaking tendencies, serves as a strategic move. The selection is more about protecting Harry from further isolation and building a supportive environment. However, it raises questions about the suitability of Ron as a prefect. Ron’s role as an approachable friend, offering comfort during difficult times, makes him an ideal candidate for the emotional support role of a prefect. Nevertheless, his troublemaking history puts him at odds with the traditional image of a prefect.

Personal Reflections and Alternatives

From a personal perspective, one might hope that Dumbledore would have chosen someone more academically inclined or emotionally intelligent. Ron’s heroic actions and caring nature make him a better choice for an approachable prefect, yet his troublemaking habits make him less suitable for the traditional prefect role. Dean Thomas, with his demonstrated ability to mediate, could have been a better alternative, given his potential to be both academically strong and emotionally supportive.

Whether Ron should have been a prefect or not remains a matter of debate. Dumbledore's decision was based on the greater good and protection of Harry, but it also sacrifices the traditional values of a prefect. Ron’s unique qualities and his role in the story make him a valuable prefect, but his shortcomings as a troublemaker highlight the importance of a prefect who embodies both discipline and emotional support.