Strategic Analysis: Why Doesn't Brienne Ask the Tarth Soldiers to Come to Winterfell?

Brienne of Tarth, renowned for her unwavering loyalty and sense of duty, faces numerous challenges when deciding whether to summon the Tarth soldiers to Winterfell. This decision is influenced by various factors, including military strategy, trust in existing forces, and the urgency of the situation.

Loyalty and Duty

Brienne's primary loyalty lies with her oaths and those she serves. At the time, her focus is on protecting Sansa Stark and upholding her vow to Lady Stark. Her dedication to these tasks may override the necessity to rally more forces, as her immediate responsibilities demand her full attention.

Strategic Concerns

Beyond her personal commitment, Brienne must also consider the potential risks of involving additional forces. The situation at Winterfell is already tense, and bringing soldiers from Tarth could exacerbate the existing complications. She may believe that more troops could create more chaos rather than genuinely assist. The unpredictable nature of the conflict with the White Walkers and the dead further complicates matters.

Communication and Timing

The urgency of the situation and the rapidly evolving nature of the conflict make effective communication challenging. With the White Walkers and the dead advancing swiftly, there might not have been enough time or means to contact the Tarth soldiers effectively. This highlights the critical importance of timely and clear communication in wartime operations.

Trust in Allies

Brienne places great trust in the forces already assembled at Winterfell, including Northern lords and their armies. She may feel confident that these existing alliances and forces are sufficient to handle the threat without needing to seek additional reinforcements. Her focus is often on her immediate companions and quest rather than broader military strategy.

Personal Journey

Throughout her journey, Brienne undergoes significant personal growth, and her commitment to honor serves as a strong guiding principle. Her character arc emphasizes her dedication to her immediate objectives and companions rather than a broad, strategic approach.

While Brienne's decision not to call for reinforcements shows her focus and loyalty, it also highlights the complexities of leadership and the challenges of navigating a dangerous and uncertain battlefield.

Alternatives and Future Outcomes

Despite Brienne's decision, there is always a chance that reinforcements will arrive. Past episodes have provided clues that could support this idea. For instance, Sam Tarly's statement in Season 7 Episode 5 suggests that if Brienne can convey the urgency of the situation clearly, she could rally the lords to send men to Winterfell.

Moreover, the possibility of reinforcements coming from Essos or Valyria adds a layer of complexity to the situation. Whether it's Melisandre, Daario Naharis, or an army of R'hllor followers, the potential arrival of these forces could alter the course of the battle dramatically.

In conclusion, Brienne's decision not to ask the Tarth soldiers to come to Winterfell is a multifaceted choice driven by loyalty, strategic concerns, and the unique nature of the conflict. While it may seem like a risk, it reflects her character's strengths and limitations. The possibility of reinforcements, however, remains an intriguing aspect of the narrative, suggesting the ever-changing dynamics of war and strategic alliances.