Why Didn’t House Stark Wipe Out the Boltons Earlier?: The Complex Dynamics Behind Their Survival

“Too kind and honorable” can be dismissed as an oversimplification. Ned Stark, known for his noble traits, was just the first in a long line of Starks who demonstrated a willingness to eliminate even their closest kin for the greater good.

Context and Historical Precedents

The Starks had a history of wiping out rival houses, such as the Greystarks. The Greystarks, who were originally the owners of the Wolf's Den, joined forces with the Boltons against House Stark of Winterfell during a rebellion. Despite their kinship, the Starks ultimately destroyed the Greystarks, indicating a willingness to eliminate betrayal for the sake of loyalty and order.

Plot Armor and Character Dynamics

While characters like Tywin and Roose Bolton may benefit from plot armor, it's important to recognize the broader narrative context. The survival of Ramsay, Gregor Clegane, and Euron Greyjoy, despite their heinous actions, serves to emphasize the themes of fate and paradoxical outcomes in the story.

The Missing Extinction of House Greyjoy

The matter of how House Greyjoy, led by Balon and later Theon, captured and held Winterfell with minimal forces also highlights the unforeseeable nature of success and survival in Westeros.

Theories Behind the Survival of House Bolton

Several explanations propose why the Boltons have survived:

1. Perceived Worse Betrayal: The Greystarks' betrayal was deemed far worse than that of the Boltons, which is why they faced a harsher consequence. Their actions were seen as a greater threat to Stark interests, justifying their annihilation.

2. Casual Death During Rebellion: Another theory suggests that the Greystarks did not escape but perished in the fighting that accompanied the rebellion. This interpretation presents a more nuanced understanding of their fate without implying direct annihilation.

3. Unresolved Historical Bonds: The boldest and most intriguing hypothesis is that there is a deeper, unexplored relationship between the Boltons and Starks that necessitates their survival. This idea adds a layer of complexity, suggesting a potential supernatural or familial bond that binds the two houses.

Supernatural Elements and Historical Resonance

Delving into the potential supernatural underpinnings, it's worth noting that the Starks are known for their ability in the art of skinchanging, bonding with animals. In contrast, the Boltons lack this ability. This difference might have fueled their animosity, leading to a kind of supernatural jealousy and competition. The Boltons' flaying ritual could be interpreted as an attempt to emulate the Starks' skinchanging abilities. Ramsay's "dirty ice" eyes and the Bolton pavilion made from human skins further suggest a parallel between psychopathic behavior and supernatural prowess.

Conclusion

The survival of House Bolton raises complex questions about history, fate, and the intricate power dynamics in Westeros. Whether it's due to perceived betrayal, casual deaths during conflict, or a mystical bond, the narrative's enduring mystery keeps readers engaged. The Boltons' oddness and continued existence serve as a powerful reminder of the convoluted nature of loyalty, honor, and power in the Seven Kingdoms.