Why Choose to Be an Extra in Film or TV Over a Professional Actor: Insights on Benefits and Remuneration

For many people, the allure of appearing in a film or TV show is a dream that remains elusive due to the competitive and notoriously demanding nature of the industry. While aspiring actors typically undergo extensive training and work hard to join the ranks of professional actors, others might find themselves more comfortable immersing themselves in the world of film and TV as an extra. This article explores the reasons behind choosing to be an extra and compares the pay and training required for both professions.

Why Become an Extra?

The decision to become an extra in a film or television production can be driven by a variety of reasons. For many, it offers a perfect balance between the glamour of being in front of the camera and the less intense demands of the role. Being an extra, also known as a background actor, allows individuals to:

Enjoy a Sense of Belonging: Working as a background actor provides a community-like environment where individuals can feel part of a larger production. Learn the Craft: Observing professional actors can be an invaluable learning experience, offering insights into performance techniques and the production process. Participate Easily: Unlike professional actors, extras do not need to undergo rigorous training or adhere to stringent requirements, making it a more accessible path. Create a Resumé: Even if just for a short scene, being part of a film or TV production can significantly enhance one's resumé and open doors to new opportunities.

Is There a Difference in Pay?

A significant distinction between being an extra and a professional actor lies in the pay structure. Unlike professional actors who are typically union members and their pay is regulated by organizations such as SAG-AFTRA (Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists), extras are compensated differently:

Extras: The payment for extras is usually much lower and can be paid per day, per day and per hour, or on a per diem basis. Extras are often provided with a meal during the production, but not always. Professional Actors: Actors, on the other hand, are compensated according to union standards, ensuring a more stable and higher income. They also receive better benefits including healthcare, pension plans, and potentially residuals if their scenes are re-used.

The disparity in pay can be stark, especially when considering the long hours and commitment required for a starring role. Extras might spend hours or even days on a set and earn only a small fraction of what a talented actor would receive for a single scene. However, this difference in pay also reflects the different time commitments and responsibilities of each profession.

Is Training Required for Extras?

One of the key differences between actors and extras is the level of training required. Professional actors usually undergo formal training in order to develop and hone their skills, whether it be through a conservatory, drama school, or intensive courses. This training is often a significant investment in time and money.

Contrastingly, being an extra does not require formal training. To be a member of the background acting community, one only needs to be able to follow simple directions and have a willingness to blend in with the crowd. This accessibility makes it an attractive option for individuals who are passionate about the film industry but do not have the time or resources to invest in extensive training.

Are Extras Considered Actors?

Despite the similarities in roles, extras are not considered actors in the traditional sense. Professional actors are often viewed as the nucleus of the production, responsible for delivering the core performances that drive the narrative. Extras, while contributing to the visual and emotional landscape of a scene, do not have the same level of creative or emotional responsibility.

As a result, if a background actor were to list themselves as an actor on their resume or apply for acting roles, they would be misrepresenting their experience. While being an extra can be a stepping stone to becoming a professional actor, the roles are distinct and should be acknowledged as such.

Conclusion: Choosing Between Acting and Being an Extra

The choice between being an extra and a professional actor is a deeply personal decision, influenced by a range of factors including personal goals, financial considerations, and passion for the industry. Both professions offer unique experiences and opportunities, but they also come with different responsibilities, pay structures, and pathways for advancement.

Whether you're drawn to the thrill of being part of a production team and the camaraderie with fellow extras, or you aspire to the professional stature of a trained and respected actor, each path has its own merits. Understanding the distinctions between the two can help individuals make informed decisions about their career in the film and television industry.