What If Jane Foster Was Actually Loki? Exploring the Possibilities

Haha, that's funny! Although Loki is actually dead by the events of Avengers: Infinity War, it’s intriguing to ponder what would have happened if he had somehow found his way back to the main timeline. The LoKid TV series offers a hint that the Time Variance Authority (TVA) or Kang the Conqueror might have undone his demise in some form. However, even if Loki were to be put back into the sacred timeline, there are compelling reasons why he wouldn’t become Jane Foster.

Why Loki Wouldn't Be Jane Foster

Reason 1: Lack of Benefit for Ruling Earth
Loki, in his current state of character development, has moved on from seeking to rule Earth. His primary objective has shifted from personal gain and manipulation to a more complex, albeit misguided, desire to prove his worth to Thor. Becoming Jane Foster would not only be an arbitrary transformation but it also wouldn't serve his new goals. Ruling Earth is no longer his primary focus; instead, rebuilding his fractured relationship with Thor and his place within the Asgardian hierarchy takes precedence.

Reason 2: Thor’s Reaction
Thor wouldn’t likely take kindly to a transformation that Loki would force upon Jane. Jane is not only Thor’s partner and love interest but also someone he deeply loves and trusts. If Jane were to suddenly become Loki, Thor’s instinct would be to protect her. He would likely use any means necessary, including force, to restore her to her original state. This could lead to a confrontation where Loki might be severely injured or even exiled from Midgard, undoing any potential progress he has made in his character arc.

Character Development and the Sacred Timeline

Character Arc in Thor: Ragnarok
By the time the events of Ragnarok conclude, Loki has undergone a significant transformation. He has matured immensely and, for the first time, placed the well-being of his brother Thor above his personal desires. This reconciliation and mutual acceptance provide a sense of closure and redemption for both characters. Dispelling this newfound harmony would be detrimental to both Loki's and Thor’s character development. It would revert Loki to his earlier, more chaotic self, jeopardizing the positive changes he has undergone.

Meeting Thor in a Familiar Form
If Loki were ever to be put back into the sacred timeline, it is highly probable that he would manifest in a form that is recognizable and familiar to the audience. Specifically, this form would resemble Tom Hiddleston’s portrayal of Loki from the main Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) films. The familiarity and validation of his original self would help in maintaining the continuity of his character's journey and ensure a smoother transition for viewers.

The Death of Loki

Some argue that the death of Loki in Avengers: Endgame and Loki (TV Series) is just too definitive to be reversed. LoKid clearly showed that the version of Loki which exists in the main Marvel Universe is indeed dead. This definitive end serves as a clear and resounding message to the audience about the irreversibility of certain events within the MCU. However, the concept of What If? still captivates fans and invites speculation about broader time-bending and alternate reality scenarios.

Though the death of Loki is final, the What If? scenario provides an intriguing loophole for fans to explore. It challenges the conventional timeline and invites us to imagine the impossible, heightening the mystery and depth of the MCU universe.