Understanding the Controversy Surrounding Tate in American Horror Story: Season One

The complex character of Tate in American Horror Story: Murder House has generated a great deal of controversy, with many viewers questioning his motives and actions. Despite the television show suggesting the house was the culprit behind Tate's violent and manipulative behavior, the reality doesn't align with this narrative. Let's delve deeper into the reasons why Tate has garnered such intense hate, focusing on his actions rather than the show's portrayal.

Why Does Tate Receive So Much Hate?

Tate receives a significant amount of hate due to his character’s deeply troubling behavior. He is not just a problematic figure but a full-blown villain who has committed tragic acts. Not only is he a school shooter, responsible for the senseless deaths of 15 students, but he is also a rapist. In one of the defining scenes of the first season, Tate infiltrates the school as Ben Harmon and rapes Vivien Harmon, leading to a pregnancy with an out-of-body baby known as the Anti-Christ. This event is later revisited in AHS: Apocalypse, but the original portrayal remains resolute in highlighting Tate's heinous actions.

Tate's Motivations and Actions

Even when the characters of the show blame the house for Tate's violent outbursts, the truth is that his actions are rooted in his own devious plans. His rape of Violet's mother, Nora, was a conscious choice made to fulfill Nora's desire for a child. Tate did not act on impulse but made a deliberate decision to impregnate her, emphasizing his control and manipulation. This can be seen clearly through Tate's interactions with Nora in one of the first season's episodes.

Furthermore, Tate consistently lies to Violet to keep her by his side. His manipulation of Violet is evident in their romantic relationship, where he takes advantage of her emotional needs to maintain his control. This is a significant factor in his targeting of the vulnerable Violet, who finds herself in a deeply unhealthy and coercive relationship. The fact that Violet actually believes she loves Tate, driven by her need for attention from a parent, makes her complicity in the relationship appear even more tragic.

Antidote to the Narrative

It reflects Evan Peters' remarkable acting ability that viewers are able to see beyond Tate's villainy to appreciate his complexity. While Tate's actions are unquestionably evil, he is crafted as an anti-hero rather than a one-dimensional villain. His character's journey is a powerful testament to the darker aspects of human nature, and his interactions with Violet provide a significant emotional depth to the narrative. This duality makes it even more disturbing that Tate is capable of such evil while remaining somewhat sympathetic on a personal level.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, Tate is a figure shrouded in controversy. His actions as a school shooter and a rapist are inarguably despicable. However, the narrative of American Horror Story: Murder House attempts to absolve him through the agency of the house. This backtracking undermines the severity of his crimes and does a disservice to the memory of those affected by his actions. It is vital to remember the real reasons Tate receives so much hate: his willingness to manipulate and disgraceful actions that cause lasting harm.

In the spirit of understanding and critical analysis, it is important to question the motives of characters like Tate and not blindly follow the show's narrative. While Tate serves a dramatic and thematic purpose in the series, his character should not be underestimated or romanticized. His actions are a stark reminder of the need for consciousness and accountability in our lives and in the stories we tell.