Ultraman vs. Space Giants: A Nostalgic Comparison of Classic Japanese SF Shows

For many of us who grew up in the 1970s or 1980s, the two most iconic television shows of the time from Japan were undoubtedly Ultraman and Space Giants. These shows left an indelible mark on our childhoods, offering wonders and excitement that continue to resonate today. Let's delve into a nostalgic comparison of the two series and discuss why Ultraman emerged as the clear favorite for many fans.

Ultraman: A Battle Royale of Mythical Proportions?

Ultraman began its run in 1966 and has continued to captivate audiences for over five decades. This series is often cited as a cornerstone of Japanese SF (Science Fiction), and for good reason. The show features a hero who battles against a wide array of monsters and aliens, each with their own unique and terrifying powers. Ultraman's iconic costume and power ray weapon are simply unmatched, making each confrontation a spectacle of action and spectacle.

One of the standout features of Ultraman is its dynamic and diverse roster of foes. From prehistoric brutes to technologically advanced aliens capable of standing on par with Ultraman, the show never fails to deliver a gripping narrative. The monsters in Ultraman are not just generic creatures but complex beings with their own characteristics, making them memorable and intriguing. Whether it’s a man-eating plant, ninja lobsters, a suicidal kaiju too fat to move, or even a telekinetic soccer ball, the creativity and imagination behind the monsters are truly compelling.

Another aspect that elevates Ultraman is its well-rounded adult characters. These characters, with their distinct personalities and complex plots, give the series a mature edge, making it more than just a simple hero vs. monster show. The character development in Ultraman is nuanced and engaging, making it a show that can be enjoyed on multiple levels.

Space Giants: A Childhood Fantasy Come True

Although Space Giants is also a beloved show, it plays a different role in the pantheon of Japanese SF. This series, while still exciting, has a softer, more whimsical tone that is perfect for a younger audience. The heroes, Gam and Zaton, are kids who transform into characters with superhero prowess. The plot of Space Giants often revolves around saving the world from various monsters, but the emphasis is on the kids’ journey of self-discovery and growth.

The kids in Space Giants are central to the story, with adults playing secondary roles. This shift in focus can make Space Giants feel somewhat like a more straightforward family show, which is comforting and familiar for many viewers. However, it also means that the story can sometimes drag and feel less engaging than the dynamic character development seen in Ultraman.

Monster Suits: A Galactic Comparison

One cannot discuss Ultraman and Space Giants without mentioning their signature feature: the monster suits. Ultraman's costume is a marvel of design and engineering, with every detail contributing to the awe-inspiring visual that graces our screens. Each monster in Ultraman is meticulously crafted and memorable, from the primitive brutes to the technologically advanced foes.

In contrast, the monsters in Space Giants are often criticized for lacking the same level of creativity and design. They are typically portrayed as overblown, cartoonish brutes with a single, albeit impressive, special power. While this can be entertaining, it doesn’t quite capture the same sense of wonder and respect that Ultraman's monsters evoke.

Concluding Thoughts: A Classic with a Heart

While both Space Giants and Ultraman are highly regarded in the realm of Japanese SF, it is Ultraman that stands out as the superior show for many fans. The intricate plots, diverse and memorable monsters, and the engaging adult characters in Ultraman make it a more sophisticated and mature series. Despite its initial cheesy appeal, the craftsmanship and creativity behind Ultraman have allowed it to endure for decades, captivating new generations with each new episode or movie release.

For those who grew up in the 1970s and 1980s, Ultraman is not just a show but a cultural icon. Its influence can be seen in countless other series and movies, and its legacy is an enduring testament to the power of imagination and storytelling. So, while both shows hold a special place in the hearts of many, Ultraman remains the true champion of classic Japanese SF.