Training of Elves in Rivendell: A Study in Allegiance and Fleeing Evil

The epic tale of Middle-earth, crafted by J.R.R. Tolkien, is replete with tales of valor, treachery, and the eternal struggle against evil. One notable aspect in this narrative is the varied response of elven kind to the defeat of Sauron and the aftermath of the destruction of the One Ring. Why did some elves, notably those led by Gil-Galad and Elrond, choose to live in the elven haven of Rivendell, while others sought refuge elsewhere? This article delves into the complexities of allegiance and the desire to flee the shadow of Mordor.

The Death of Gil-Galad and Its Consequences

At the start of the allegory, Gil-Galad, the High King of the Noldor, met a tragic end. He was cooked to death by Sauron during the final battle of the War of the Ring. This gruesome fate rendered Gil-Galad unfit for any further leadership roles among his people, as continuing to live with him was impossible. Consequently, the rest of the elves had to look elsewhere for guidance and a place to call home.

Leadership and Follower Dynamics

The elven community rallied around various leader figures, most notably Elrond and Cirdan. Elrond, following in the footsteps of Gil-Galad, took up the mantle of leadership in Rivendell. This place, renowned for its safety and beauty, became a beacon of hope for many elves. In contrast, Cirdan, the second most significant leader, led those who felt the call to leave Middle-earth for the undying lands of Valinor, beyond the reach of any mortal power.

Decision-Making in Rivendell

Rivendell remained a home to those elves who felt content with life there and loyal to Elrond. The founding of Rivendell came after the devastating war with the orcs, where Elrond and his forces were compelled to retreat to the north following the destruction of Eregion. Despite the favorable conditions and the loyalty to Elrond, there was little reason for these elves to leave and seek out Lindon.

The Call to the West

According to the original Tolkien lore, the Valar summoned the elves to return to the Blessed Realm of Valinor. Weary from centuries of battling evil and fearing inevitable fading, many elves chose to leave Middle-earth in pursuit of a new and undying future.

Rivendell's Strategic Significance

Rivendell, positioned strategically as the fortress of Elrond under the command of Gil-Galad, played a crucial role in the defense of Middle-earth. This position was established in the aftermath of Sauron's attacks, as Gil-Galad sent Elrond to Eregion to protect the Second Age's precious rings of power.

Elrond's Leadership and Fated Decisions

Elrond, though not directly responsible for Gil-Galad's death, played a pivotal role in the events leading to Sauron's defeat. He was instrumental in urging Isildur to destroy the One Ring by casting it into the fires, a decision that would affect Middle-earth's fate profoundly. Additionally, Elrond's survival during key battles, such as the destruction of Eregion, allowed him to lead the elves of Rivendell into a peaceful and prosperous existence.

Elrond's leadership in Rivendell, marked by both protection and counsel, offered a safe haven for those elves who wished to stay in Middle-earth and honor their past while looking to a brighter future.

Thus, the choice of living in Rivendell, led by Elrond, stood as a testament to the elven resolve to face the aftermath of evil, alongside a desire to honor and preserve their heritage.