The Unfulfilled Potential of Merlin: An Analysis of the Favored Ending

The Favored Ending in Detail

Merlin, the popular British television series, comes to a close with a storyline that, while popular with many viewers, leaves significant room for improvement and alternative narratives. The favored ending, though complex, does not fully satisfy the many fan theories and expectations that surrounded the final season.

First and foremost, the death of King Arthur is a pivotal moment that disrupts the expected narrative arc. Arthur, after discovering Merlin's true powers, dies without having the chance to truly embrace or challenge them. This culminates in a bittersweet ending, with Merlin revealing his involvement in every great feat that Arthur achieved, suggesting a deeper intertwining of destinies that goes unexplored.

Rushed and Contradictory Elements

The favored ending is often critiqued for its rushed and somewhat contradictory elements. This critique encompasses several key aspects: the sudden brainwashing of Guinevere, the lack of conflict involving other significant characters like Morgana and Mordred, and the hasty conclusion of Camelot's history.

For instance, the portrayal of Guinevere unwittingly violating the magic ban, a plot point that seems to contradict her character development throughout the series, is seen as a convenience to expedite the ending. Similarly, the absence of a significant showdown between Merlin and Morgana, both major antagonists, leaves a sense of unfinished business. This omission makes the resolution feel unsatisfying, especially given the buildup of conflict between them over the course of the series.

Alternative Scenarios: An Ocean of Possibilities

Some viewers, including the author of this critique, believe that the series could have explored a richer and more fulfilling conclusion. Suggestions include a scenario where Arthur accepts and incorporates Merlin's powers, potentially lifting the magic ban and ushering in a new era of Camelot. This could have been depicted through a series of episodes showing the transition, allowing viewers to witness the evolution of Arthur and his kingdom.

Additionally, there could have been a more complex interaction between Merlin and Morgana. An epic showdown where both characters use all their powers and abilities to determine their fate would have provided a memorable and resonant conclusion. This could also have established Merlin as a revered figure, perhaps even being appointed a 'magician title' for the king, marking a significant milestone in his journey.

Furthermore, instead of a rushed conclusion, there could have been more episodes dedicated to the period following Arthur's death, showing how Camelot and Albion evolved. This could have included periods of both prosperity and turmoil, thereby painting a fuller picture of the 'Golden Age.' Such episodes would have given viewers a sense of continuity and closure, providing deeper insights into the long-term impact of Merlin's actions on Camelot.

Final Scene Decoded

The final scene, showing Merlin as an old man walking through a modern English city, has sparked much debate. Some suggest that this could be Winchester, often described as the modern-day Camelot, while others interpret it as a symbol of immortality achieved either through personal endeavors or destiny ties to Arthur. However, this ending, while evocative, remains somewhat underutilized in terms of storytelling.

Viewers would likely appreciate a more detailed exploration of Merlin's journey from his mysterious transformation to his final destination. This would not only fulfill the narrative arc but also provide a more profound understanding of Merlin's character and his significance in the grand tapestry of Arthurian legend.

Conclusion

In summary, while the favored ending of the Merlin series has its merits and resonates with many fans, its rushed and contradictory nature leaves much room for improvement. Alternative narratives with a more fulfilling resolution, a better depiction of Merlin and Morgana's final confrontation, and a deeper exploration of Camelot's future would have significantly enhanced the series' legacy. Fans and creators alike can draw valuable lessons from this analysis to inform future narrative developments in television and beyond.