The Unforeseen Path: Gendry’s Legitimacy and His Journey with Arya

Would it be a good ending if Gendry refused his legitimacy and join Arya on her adventures? This question brings us to a compelling scenario that intertwines Gendry and Arya Stark, two iconic characters from the A Song of Ice and Fire series. While the original series provided a different path for their characters, this hypothetical scenario explores their potential future.

After her myriad adventures and the exhausting journey of beholden to her fate, would Arya benefit from the companionship of Gendry? Alternatively, should Gendry work on his role as the Lord of Storm’s End and take on responsibilities of leadership? While it may appear that joining Arya would decompress her, the reality of her restless nature might make this a difficult choice.

Arya's Evolution: From Struggle to Restlessness

After 12 years away from home, Arya has returned without a place to call her own. From the dozen or so different places she has resided, none have managed to become a home. This restlessness is a defining trait of Arya Stark, and it is likely that she would find reunion with Gendry and Storm’s End too restricting.

Gendry: The Unassuming Hero

Gendry, on the other hand, has shown a different path in A Song of Ice and Fire. He is a man who aspires to settle down, unlike the restless Arya. Despite his ambitious nature, his journey has often been marked by a need to seek shelter and work rather than adventure. His experiences include working in King’s Landing, Harrenhal, and even joining the Brotherhood without Banners, before returning to King’s Landing.

Given his lifestyle up to this point, Gendry’s primary focus is on acquiring his title and lands. While it might be too much to turn down for a man who has faced poverty, the responsibilities of being a Lord Paramount of the Stormlands would be daunting and overwhelming for Gendry. His lack of education and experience in such a position would make this path challenging.

Turn Down For What?

When Arya refused Gendry during their previous meeting, his excitement waned. He had envisioned a future where they were of equal standing, allowing him to marry her and take on the role of Lord. However, Arya’s refusal had shattered his dreams, indicating her disinterest in settling down just yet.

Embracing the Unpredictable Path

Instead of following a path where Gendry would join Arya’s adventures, it would be more intriguing to explore their relationship under different circumstances. Gendry could marry a woman who is willing to help him with his responsibilities, and Arya could continue her journey on her own terms. They could meet at a tourney and discover a mutual feeling, leading to a relation where both parties can thrive.

In this scenario, Gendry could work on being the Lord of Storm’s End, participating in the duties of leadership, and sometimes going on expeditions with Arya. Alternately, they could return to the sea and live a more nomadic, adventurous life together. This path allows both characters to grow and develop in ways that align with their individual nature.

Conclusion

It would be sad to see a character like Gendry, who has shown signs of contentment in his current life, throw away his dreams to follow Arya. Their unique journey offers a mixture of adventure and responsibility, making for a compelling narrative. Whether they choose to join forces or remain on separate paths, it is clear that both characters possess a strength that can guide them through the unpredictable and sometimes tumultuous world they live in.

Ultimately, the power of their relationship lies in the balance of their individual growth and the respect they have for each other’s paths. Their story can continue to evolve in ways that are true to their characters and the rich world of A Song of Ice and Fire.