The Tully Family's Allegiance in Westeros: Brynden Tully and His Great-Nephew Robb Stark

Often portrayed as a complex character in the intricate web of Westerosi politics, Brynden Tully, also known as the Blackfish, is a significant figure in the narrative. Despite common misconceptions, his loyalties lie primarily with his family, most notably with his great-nephew, Robb Stark. This article explores Brynden Tully's involvement in various conflicts, particularly during the War of the Five Kings, and his unwavering commitment to his family over any personal claims or external pressures.

Understanding Brynden Tully

Brynden Tully's loyalty is rooted in his family connections, especially his relationship with Catelyn Stark, the mother of Robb Stark, and his role as Robb's great uncle. As the son of Hoster Tully and the brother of Lysa Arryn, Brynden has long supported the Tully family's deep-seated values of family, duty, and honor.

Family Ties: Brynden's connection to Robb Stark is not just familial but also deeply rooted in his commitment to the Tully family. When Robb Stark began his journey to establish his claim to the North and Riverlands, Brynden, despite being stationed in the Vale, could not ignore his maternal niece and great-nephew in their time of need.

The War of the Five Kings: Brynden Tully's Involvement

Historically, Brynden Tully's involvement in the War of the Five Kings has been a subject of debate. Many mistakenly associate him with Renly Baratheon's claim, but this claim garnered support primarily from the Reach and Stormlands, not the Riverlands. Brynden was not aligned with Renly; rather, he was a staunch supporter of Robb Stark's claim.

The Vale and Northern Allegiance

When the war broke out, Brynden's presence was crucial in the Riverlands and the North. Despite his initial station in the Vale, with the war's outbreak, his loyalty shifted. The deeper his family's involvement in the war became, the more Brynden's presence was needed. His departure from the Vale to join the Northern and Riverlands army underscores his commitment to the family's honor and duty.

The Blackfish's Loyalty

Popularly known as the Blackfish, Brynden Tully's loyalty extends back to his younger days, when he accompanied Lysa Arryn to the Vale. Although he had initially been ordered to stay out of all conflicts, the war's start aligned his interests with those of Catelyn and Robb. The values ingrained in the Tully family, as exemplified by their motto, "Family, Duty, Honor," compelled Brynden to abandon his Vale duties and join the fight.

Brynden Tully and Robert's Rebellion

The events of Robert's Rebellion are another dimension of Brynden Tully's historical significance. Though he did not provide specific details on his involvement, his service as the Knight of the Gate in the Vale indicates his role in the conflict. This period further cemented his allegiance to House Tully, particularly in light of their joint opposition to Aerys II's unjust murder of House Stark's members, Brandon and Rickard Stark.

Support for Robb Stark's Claim

Brynden Tully's support for Robb Stark's claim to the North and Riverlands is not merely coincidental but a reflection of his deep-seated loyalty to the Tully family. Robb Stark's youthful leadership, which often drew comparisons to his father, Eddard, resonated with Brynden's sense of duty and family honor. The Tully family's past history of fighting against the unjust rule of Aerys II makes Brynden's support for Robb's cause a natural extension of their shared values.

Conclusion

Understanding Brynden Tully's role in Westeros requires recognizing his unwavering commitment to his family's values and his familial ties. His involvement in various conflicts, from the War of the Five Kings to Robert's Rebellion, is a testament to his loyalty and duty. Brynden Tully's actions, particularly his support for Robb Stark, highlight the importance of family and honor in a world where conflict looms large.

As we navigate the complex political landscape of Westeros, it is crucial to remember the historical context and the core values that drive characters like Brynden Tully and Robb Stark. Their relationship and loyalty serve as a powerful reminder of the enduring impact of family ties in times of strife and uncertainty.