The Sopranos: Could Sean, Matt, and Jackie Jr. Have Formed a Deadly Partnership?

It's a common observation among fans of The Sopranos that the stories of Sean Gismonte, Matt Bevilaqua, and Jackie Jr. might have intersected in a far more significant way than the show initially depicted. This hypothetical collaboration would certainly have been a compelling storyline, but would it have ultimately saved any of their lives? Let's delve into the potential outcomes if these three had joined forces and considered the reasons why it might not have been a wise decision.

Meeting Under Deceased Circumstances

Sean Gismonte and Matt Bevilaqua were long gone by the time viewers were introduced to Jackie Jr. in the final moments of Season 2. However, if these three had somehow found themselves working together, their collective fate would have remained grim. All three characters shared a common trait: they were all considered expendable and lacked the necessary acumen to survive within the cutthroat world of the Mafia.

A Comparative Assessment of Intelligence and Ambition

Sean, Matt, and Jackie Jr. all exhibited a certain level of naivety and recklessness, which ultimately led to their downfall. Sean and Matt's ultimate plan to bring down Christopher Moltisanti backfired spectacularly, leading to their current status as deceased individuals. On the other hand, Jackie Jr.'s ambitious yet ill-conceived scheme to rob Eugene Pontecorvo's card game ended in disaster, resulting in violence, injuries, and the wrath of powerful mobsters.

Partnership and the Ties That Bind

Assuming that Sean, Matt, and Jackie Jr. had met and teamed up, their partnership would not have provided any significant advantage. Sean and Matt were already under the protection of Christopher Moltisanti, a made guy. Considering their track record of poor decisions and lack of strategic thinking, it's improbable that they would have sought out the help of someone as inexperienced as Jackie Jr.

The Role of Christopher Moltisanti

Christopher Moltisanti would have played a critical role in any such partnership. If the trio had attempted to pursue their plans, Christopher, who was present at the card game, would have quickly recognized Matt's and Sean's voices. This would have reignited the conflict of honor and loyalty, further jeopardizing any chance of survival for the group. Even if no one had been physically harmed, their actions would still have been seen as a severe insult to the organization, potentially leading to their immediate termination.

Concluding the Confusion

Given their previous behaviors and the nature of the Mafia, it's highly unlikely that Sean and Matt would have risked their lives for the sake of supporting Jackie Jr. Their alignment with Christopher would have been a significant factor, and their previous efforts would have left them untrusted and unneeded. Thus, if they attempted to collaborate with Jackie Jr. and were involved in the disastrous robbery, all three would have ended up joining their mentor, Christopher, in the grave.