Who Was More Respected in Westeros: The Starks or the Tyrells?

In the lavish and tumultuous world of Westeros, several great houses wielded varying degrees of respect and influence. At the heart of the story stand two particularly prominent ones: the Starks and the Tyrells. Each held a different type of respect and influence, largely shaped by their respective roles and characteristics.

Elevated Elegance: House Stark of Winterfell

House Stark, also known as the Baratheons in the North under Robert Baratheon, is renowned for its honor, loyalty, and strong sense of duty. They are often depicted as the moral backbone of the North, embodying the famous Stark motto: “Winter is Coming.”

The Starks commanded respect due to their noble lineage, strategic leadership in controlling the North, and their unwavering commitment to justice and the well-being of their family. Their values resonated deeply with many, especially after the tragic losses experienced during the War of the Five Kings. Their honor and resilience were evident even in their lowest moments, as seen in the eventual downfall of House Stark, which only served to highlight their exceptional integrity.

Prosperity and Political Savvy: House Tyrell of Highgarden

In contrast, House Tyrell from Highgarden is characterized by wealth, political savvy, and a more opportunistic approach to power. They are known for their immense influence in the Reach, one of the most fertile and populous regions in Westeros.

The Tyrells gained respect through their prosperity and their ability to navigate the complex political landscape. Notably, their alliance with the Lannisters and their subsequent influence in the capital gave them significant power during the reign of King Tommen Baratheon. However, they were often viewed as being more calculating and less honorable than the Starks, a perception that affected their reputation even as their political influence grew.

A Comparison of Influence and Admiration

Overall, the Starks were generally more respected for their integrity and adherence to principles. Their steadfast and unwavering sense of honor often stood out more starkly in times of crisis, as seen in their relentless defense of the North and their moral defiance in the face of adversity. In contrast, the Tyrells were respected primarily for their wealth and political maneuvering, although their contributions to the stability and governance of Westeros were also noteworthy.

From Prestige to Practicality

While the Starks garnered respect through their moral and ethical conduct, the Tyrells achieved influence through their wealth and political acumen. The Starks' kingdom, from Bran the Builder to Torrhen the King, and beyond, has always been formidable and resilient. Anyone who attempted to conquer the North found it a laborious and unworthy endeavor. The Tyrells, on the other hand, rose from stewards to become the stewards of Reach, a position that, while noble, might not have been as prestigious as some of the long-held noble families.

Despite their humble origins, the Tyrells’ fertile lands and agricultural wealth made them a crucial part of feeding the kingdom, thus securing them a place of respect and honor, even among those who might normally criticize their position. Their political activity, which often outshone that of the North, which was more isolationist, also contributed to their reputation.

Recent Leadership and Legacy

When comparing the most recent leadership of both houses, Ned Stark and Mace Tyrell undoubtedly stand out with different qualities. Ned Stark, with a reputation for integrity, justice, and strength, was widely admired. His sense of justice and unwavering principles made him a formidable figure, and if not for his political and strategic missteps, he might have achieved much success, if not victory, in the Game of Thrones. In contrast, Mace Tyrell’s achievements are more centered around his political and military strategies, and he is known for his resourcefulness and ability to manipulate political situations.

While Mace Tyrell has certainly left his mark on the political landscape of Westeros, it is often Ned Stark’s honesty and adherence to principles that leave a more lasting impact. The tragic downfall of House Stark serves as a poignant reminder of the intertwined nature of honor, power, and fate in Westeros.

In conclusion, the Starks and the Tyrells held different types of respect in Westeros, with the Starks generally more respected for their integrity and principles, and the Tyrells for their wealth and political maneuvering. Despite the differences, both houses played significant roles in shaping the intricate world of Westeros, each contributing to the rich tapestry of its history and legacy.