The Perspective of Latter-day Saints on Mel Gibson’s Historical Drama, ‘Apocalypto’

As a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the cinematic experience of watching Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto has been a subject of reflection and personal endorsement. My encounter with the film, viewed once in the past, steered more towards disappointment primarily owing to its intense focus on violence and gory imagery. Although I had watched Apocalypto because of its proclaimed nature as 'historical fiction,' my interest in history could not shield me from the overwhelming portrayal of violent and bloody scenes.

Defining Historical Fiction vs. Hollywood Expectations

Historical fiction often delves deep into the gritty realities of the past, where savagery and brutality were indeed prevalent. However, as much as history might provide a invaluable perspective, its depiction on the screen does not always align with the sanitized and enlightened viewing experiences modern audiences are accustomed to. Historical narratives often incorporate these darker periods to ensure authenticity, but this can sometimes overshadow the more positive aspects of these societies.

Searching for a Balanced Historical Narrative

The efforts to provide a balanced historical perspective through cinema are commendable, yet the execution in Apocalypto was marked by a biased focus. The portrayal centered predominantly on malevolent figures perpetrating acts of violence against the protagonist and others. While the depiction of violence is indeed crucial in understanding the historical context, such an exclusive focus can overshadow the positive narratives and nuanced societal behaviors that existed. It would be beneficial for historical movies to emphasize the positive aspects of societies, even while elucidating the necessity of presenting graphic violence to maintain historical accuracy.

Examining Positive Elements in 'Apocalypto'

Upon my recollection, the sole positive aspect of Apocalypto that resonated was the loving bond that the protagonist shared with his immediate family and friends. This familial and social unity, serving as a poignant contrast against the backdrop of widespread violence, seemed to be a rare and noteworthy element in the narrative. However, the overwhelming portrayal of violence and the brutality of such actions left me with a sense of disappointment and unease.

Graphical Violence and its Impact

Graphical violence can be a double-edged sword in historical dramas. On one hand, it upholds a duty to accurately represent the conditions of the past, which is essential for educational and cultural purposes. On the other hand, it can be so overwhelming that it detracts from the overall storytelling and viewer engagement. Personally, I prefer movies that handle violence less graphically, as it allows for a more nuanced and layered exploration of historical events.

Conclusion

In summation, as a member of the Latter-day Saints, my preference for historical narratives leans towards a balanced and more comprehensive exploration of societies of the past. Apocalypto serves as a case study in this regard, where an overemphasis on violence and bloodiness can overshadow the positive and enriching stories that history has to offer. Future historical dramas should strive to present a more equitable and varied portrayal of ancient societies, ensuring that viewers are not only aware of the grim realities but also the hope and unity that defined them.