The Journey of Commander Riker: How Jonathan Frakes Outshone Billy Campbell

In the vast universe of Star Trek: The Next Generation, the role of Commander William Riker is one of the most pivotal. But who was chosen to fill this crucial position? How did Jonathan Frakes outshine Billy Campbell, who appeared briefly as the title character in one episode? This article explores the behind-the-scenes story of this casting decision.

Jonathan Frakes' Audition and Chemistry

Jonathan Frakes was chosen to play Commander William Riker in Star Trek: The Next Generation primarily due to his strong audition and the chemistry he demonstrated with the other cast members. Frakes brought a charismatic and deeply nuanced presence to the character, which resonated with the show's producers, especially creator Gene Roddenberry and executive producer Rick Berman.

During the audition process, Frakes's range and ability to portray Riker's strengths and vulnerabilities were highly praised. His strong background in theater also significantly contributed to his screen presence. Frakes's selection was crucial in helping shape Riker into one of the beloved characters in the Star Trek franchise.

Billy Campbell's Brief Appearance

Billy Campbell, on the other hand, played the one-off title character in a single episode. Despite his brief appearance, the casting team recognized the need for an actor who could not only portray Riker's strengths but also his vulnerabilities. However, Frakes's audition showcased a compelling balance that ultimately secured his role.

The Role's Necessity: A Commander Lacking in the Classic Sense

Jeffrey Combs auditioned for the role but did not secure it. Instead, Frakes's portrayal was seen as an essential component of the show. In the docuseries 'The Center Seat, Hosted by Gates McFadden', Gates mentions how they intentionally cast Patrick Stewart as Picard, an opposite to the iconic James Kirk. This decision underscored the need for Riker to embody a similar leadership quality but with his own unique traits.

Frakes was chosen to be the personification of a "Kirk-like" commander, one that could fit within the established universe of Star Trek without stepping too far from the original canon. Gene Roddenberry's vision required someone who could be a charming, flirtatious ladies' man, much like what viewers saw in "The Outrageous Okana."

Productions Team and Star Trek's Legendary Producer

Initially, there was widespread revolt from the rest of the production team, including Obi-Wan Kenobi actor Billy Campbell, who was surprisingly passed over for the role. Roddenberry, who was very invested in Riker as a charming and flirtatious figure, supported Campbell’s interpretation.

However, the casting team's concerns were validated when one of the writers asked Gene Roddenberry a thought-provoking question: What would it be like to be under fire with someone like Campbell's interpretation of Riker in command? A veteran himself, Roddenberry ultimately conceded to the writers' point. Frakes's ability to bring a sense of depth and leadership to the role was indeed vital for the series' success.

The selection of Jonathan Frakes for the role of Commander Riker remains a telling moment in the history of Star Trek: The Next Generation, showcasing the importance of chemistry, casting, and the right fit for a character as integral to futuristic storytelling as William Riker.