The Impact of Balon Greyjoy’s Allied Forces with Robb Stark during the War of the Five Kings

Imagine a scenario where Balon Greyjoy, the ironborn ruler of the Iron Islands, had allied with Robb Stark, the young and ambitious ruler of the North, during the tumultuous period of the War of the Five Kings. This alliance could have profoundly changed the course of the conflict in Westeros, leading to significant shifts in military, political, and strategic landscapes.

Strengthened Northern Forces

The most immediate consequence of such an alliance would have been a significant strengthening of the Northern forces. The merging of the strongholds of the North with the formidable naval capabilities of the Iron Islands would have created a formidable military presence. This combined force would have been more than a match for the Lannisters, especially in the critical Riverlands.

Combined Military Might

By uniting their resources and manpower, Balon Greyjoy and Robb Stark could have launched coordinated attacks and defended key positions more effectively. The Iron Islands' naval strength would have been a game-changer, allowing them to disrupt Lannister supply lines, control the rivers, and support coastal operations. This maritime advantage would have put immense pressure on the Lannisters, who were particularly dependent on sea trade and supply.

Strategic Objectives

Targeting Riverrun

With the Greyjoy support, the allied forces might have been able to coordinate a more effective attack on key Lannister strongholds like Riverrun. Capturing such a strategic stronghold would have bolstered Robb Stark's position, providing him with a valuable foothold in the heart of the Riverlands and significant strategic advantage.

Control of the North

An alliance could have solidified control over the North, making it much more difficult for any external forces to encroach on Stark territory. This would have allowed Robb Stark to consolidate his power base, ensuring that his rule was secure and unchallenged.

Political Ramifications

Iron Islands Autonomy

One of the potential political outcomes of this alliance could have been the pursuit of greater autonomy for the Iron Islands. Balon Greyjoy might have sought significant concessions or privileges, such as greater independence in how the Iron Islands operate. This could have led to a more decentralized and fragmented political landscape in the North, complicating alliances and consolidations.

Tension with Other Houses

However, the alliance would not have been devoid of controversy. Other Northern houses, which were either loyal to the Starks or had their own ambitions, might have seen this as a betrayal or a threat to their interests. This could have led to internal conflicts and power struggles, further destabilizing the North.

Impact on Other Factions

The Lannisters' Response

The Lannisters, facing a powerful new enemy, would have been forced to divert significant resources to counter the alliance. This diversion of resources could have weakened their position elsewhere in the war, leaving other key regions more vulnerable to challenges.

Stannis Baratheon and Renly Baratheon

The alliance might have shifted the focus of the war, compelling Stannis and Renly to reassess their strategies and form new alliances. These shifts could have altered the balance of power and the overall trajectory of the conflict.

Long-Term Consequences

The Future of the Ironborn

A successful partnership could have altered the fate of the Ironborn, potentially leading to a more influential role in the politics of Westeros. The Ironborn would have gained a reputation for diplomatic acumen and strategic prowess, which could have long-lasting implications for their status and future alliances.

Robb Stark’s Fate

If the alliance had been successful, it might have changed the circumstances of Robb Stark's eventual downfall. With a stronger military position, strategic advantages, and a unified front, he could have negotiated better terms or even secured a firmer hold on the North against external threats. However, the complex politics of Westeros would have ensured that challenges and betrayals continued to loom, making the outcome of such an alliance far from certain.

Conclusion

Overall, an alliance between Balon Greyjoy and Robb Stark could have turned the tide of the War of the Five Kings, leading to a different outcome for both the North and the Iron Islands. However, the complexities of Westerosi politics would have ensured that challenges and betrayals continued to play a critical role in the conflict, making the path to victory or defeat a perilous and uncertain one.