The Force Awakens: Would George Lucas’ Involvement Change the Film?

Had George Lucas been actively involved in the production of Star Wars: The Force Awakens, the film might have taken a very different direction. As a central figure in the franchise, it’s crucial to examine his potential impact and bring forth the discussion of whether his involvement could have improved or worsened the film.

Lucas’ Role in The Force Awakens

Star Wars: The Force Awakens was one of the most highly anticipated films of 2015, and it was clear that no other director could have brought the same level of anticipation and nostalgia. While George Lucas was initially involved in the film’s creation, his level of influence was limited. In fact, he submitted his own storyline focusing on teenage characters, but Disney declined this approach.

According to various sources and documentaries, Lucas submitted his own story treatment, which was starkly different from the final product. Daniel Richtman’s The Force Awakens: The Journey delves into the early stages of the film’s development and highlights Lucas’ involvement in story meetings. However, his story was ultimately rejected, and Lucas had no further input in the film's direction.

The Nature of Lucas’ Influence

Lucas did attend the initial stages of the film’s pre-production, serving as a creative consultant. This role meant he could provide valuable insights into the Star Wars universe, helping to maintain continuity and consistency. However, it does raise the question: would a more hands-on role have benefitted the film's creative process?

Lucas' involvement with the prequels and special editions of previous films reveals a history of reworking existing ideas and concepts. For example, the reuse of the Death Star and the droid command ship in The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones demonstrates a consistent approach to storytelling and character development. It's thus understandable that he might have brought similar elements to The Force Awakens.

Lucas’ Impact on Story and Creativity

One of the key debates surrounding Lucas' potential involvement is whether his creative style would have improved or detracted from the film. Some argue that his work with the prequels, such as the tedious rehashing of familiar elements, could have made The Force Awakens less innovative. Others highlight his ability to work within constraints and collaborate effectively, as seen in his earlier work.

On one hand, the film was praised for its accessibility and relatability, something that could have been enhanced by Lucas' influence. On the other hand, his tendency to explore ideas thoroughly and sometimes to the point of overthinking could have led to creative stagnation.

Lucas' Reactions and Apologies

After screening The Force Awakens, Lucas did express his disapproval of the film's "retro" approach. In an interview, he stated, “It was sort of like, ‘Let’s go back to the past.’ And I think that’s a nice movie, but I thought it needed to go to a different direction.” His comments sparked a controversial debate, but his subsequent apology shows a willingness to reflect on his viewpoints.

The impact of these comments is significant because they underscore the tension between tradition and innovation in the Star Wars franchise. While some fans might support Lucas' vision, the controversy also highlights the critical role of a balance between continuity and creativity in the franchise's success.

Conclusion

George Lucas' potential involvement in Star Wars: The Force Awakens would have certainly altered the direction of the film. His history with the franchise and his creative style provide a complex picture of what could have transpired. As a creative consultant, he could have offered a wealth of insights, but his influence on the franchise as a whole remains a topic of ongoing debate among fans and critics alike.

Looking at the controversies and the outcomes, does one believe that Lucas would have created a better or worse film? It’s a question that invites both speculation and admiration for the complexity of the Star Wars universe.