The Betrayal of Arianne Martell: A Mystery Unveiled in ASOIAF

The intricate plot involving Arianne Martell's switch with her decoy, Rosamund Lannister, in George R.R. Martin's Game of Thrones (ASOIAF), is a web of political intrigue and betrayal that captivates readers. The question of who betrayed the plans to switch Arianne Martell with Rosamund Lannister remains a mystery, adding another layer of complexity to the series. Let's explore the possibilities and speculate on the most likely culprits.

The Switch and Deception

The story of Arianne Martell is one filled with deception and betrayal when she switched places with her decoy, Rosamund Lannister, a girl with a Lannister appearance. This decoy acted as a double similar to Padme's double in the Star Wars series. Rosamund was initially claimed to have an illness with a rash, but closer inspection revealed the true nature of the switch. Although the original plot revealed who betrayed the plans is never definitively stated, the possibilities are intriguing.

Speculations on the Betrayer

One of the most probable candidates for the betrayer is King Aerys Targaryen. Being conflicted about betraying his own daughter, Myrcella, while trying to please his lover Arianne Martell, Aerys appears to have struggled with the guilt of telling the truth. His hasty approach to Areo Hotah, a character in the series, might indicate that he was still wrestling with the aftermath of the betrayal.

Another potential suspect is Gerold Dayne. Despite having his own subversion plans involving the assassination of Myrcella, he would likely not have revealed the plot to the Lannisters. Gerold's allegiance and his secretive nature suggest that he would not betray such a plan for his own interests, as he clearly had something to hide and was possibly involved in a wider conspiracy.

Other suspects include Andrey Holding and Sylva Dayne. While these individuals were eventually punished for their involvement in the plot, it is unlikely that they would have revealed the information in exchange for a deal, as this would have gone against their character and the context of the story.

The Final Suspect: Arys Oakheart

A final, albeit unlikely, possibility is that the person who Arys Oakheart had stand in to impersonate could have revealed the plot after they left. Arys, a key loyalist to the Martell cause, may have had a change of heart or been influenced by events that led to the revelation of the plan. However, this scenario is the least probable among the current guesses, as Arys has no apparent motive for betrayal.

While we may never know the true identity of the betrayer, the intrigue and complexity of the story keep fans engaged and speculation alive. Will the mystery of who betrayed Arianne Martell ever be fully resolved, or will it remain yet another unsolved puzzle in the vast world of ASOIAF?