Surprising Inclusions in the Pantheon of America's Greatest Writers

When discussing the list of America's greatest writers, the conversation often revolves around established literary icons like Hemingway, Faulkner, and Twain. However, what about those lesser-known authors or genre writers who might shock some readers? Join us as we explore which contemporary and once-popular American novelists would be surprising to find on a list of America's greatest writers.

The Question of 'Greatness'

The term 'America's greatest writers' can be a subjective and nebulous notion. It is not necessarily a measure of true greatness or literary merit but rather a reflection of an author's impact, cultural significance, and literary acclaim at a given time. This opens up the possibility for a diverse range of authors to be included in such a list.

Controversial Inclusions

When it comes to defining the 'America's greatest writers' club', there is room for a wide range of perspectives and interpretations. Some well-known literary giants like:

James Wharton Herman Melville Nathaniel Hawthorne Mark Twain William Faulkner

are indisputable choices. But what about lesser-known authors?

Lesser-Quàlified but Noteworthy Writers

Even writers of lesser quality but with some notable works can be considered. Think of:

Stephen Crane Edgar Allen Poe (Bierce) Jefferson Fox (Cabell) Upton Sinclair (Dreiser) Flannery O'Connor Willa Cather

These authors may not be considered the best, but they have contributed to the literary landscape of America in unique ways.

Challenging Inclusions

For some, the inclusion of:

Sherwood Anderson Yevgeny Zamyatin (Nelson Algren) Paul Bowles William Dean Howells James Gould Cozzens

might be surprising. While these authors have their merits, they may not be considered among the absolute greats.

Popular But Non-Traditional Candidates

Perhaps even more surprising would be the inclusion of:

Stephen King Rex Stout Ross Macdonald

These authors are renowned for their popular genre fiction and have produced many well-regarded works. Their inclusion might challenge the traditional view of what constitutes a 'great' writer.

Taking the List to the Next Level

But what about those who are not only vastly different in their writing but also controversial? Consider:

Harper Lee Truman Capote

While both have their admirers, their works may not hold up to the test of time the way some might expect.

Even more shockingly, the inclusion of:

Mean and vicious hacks (D.B.) Names beginning with K.F.

could truly upset the literary establishment. Acknowledging these individuals, even if only to include them for their significant impact on the genre they represent, remains a form of recognition.

So, who would you be most surprised to find on a list of America's greatest writers? The answer may depend on where one draws the line between 'great' and 'merely popular'. The debate is as lively as it is complex.