Should Star Trek: The Animated Series Be Remade with Modern CGI?

The debate about whether Star Trek: The Animated Series should be remade with modern CGI technology while preserving the original audio tracks remains quite lively in the Star Trek community. Opinions are divided on this matter, with some enthusiasts arguing for a fresh visual approach to enhance the storytelling, while others prefer maintaining the original retro animation as a testament to its historical significance.

Support for Modernization

One argument in favor of remaking Star Trek: The Animated Series with modern CGI is that advanced visual effects could potentially enhance the visuals, making the series more appealing to a new generation of viewers. Proponents suggest that stripping out the sound and rebuilding the visuals to match the original dialogue could result in a visually impressive and technologically advanced production. This approach could breathe new life into the series, making it more engaging and relevant for contemporary audiences. Additionally, it could offer opportunities to expand on the existing storyline, providing more depth and complexity to the narrative.

Concerns Over Vintage Charm and Authenticity

On the other hand, many fans of the original series believe that the retro animation gives the series its unique charm and character, and any modernization could diminish this charm. They argue that the voice actors who played the same roles in the original series have passed away, and a modern reimagining would feel alienating or creepy due to this. Some viewers feel that the nostalgia of the original animation is a significant part of the series' appeal and that modernization would strip away the retro aesthetic that has become ingrained in Star Trek culture.

Alternatives and Legacy

Another perspective contends that the modernization of Star Trek: The Animated Series would not be necessary because there are other contemporary series like Star Trek: Lower Decks and Prodigy that continue the franchise's animated legacy in a modern context. Fans of these newer shows argue that these series serve as the perfect vessel to bring the animated aspects of Star Trek into the modern era, providing a modern interpretation without compromising the retro aesthetic of the original series. Additionally, leaving TAS as it is honors the hard work of the creative team and the vision that they brought to life, preserving the legacy of those who made it possible without losing the essence of the original work.

Historical Significance and Appreciation

Fans also highlight the historical significance of the original animation. Many believe that by keeping the original animation intact, we can appreciate the technological limitations and artistic choices of the 1960s, thereby providing a deeper understanding and appreciation of modern animation techniques. Critics of modernization point out that Ted Turner's colorization of classic films serves as a cautionary tale, suggesting that alterations made in the name of progress can sometimes detract from the original experience and the historical context that makes the original work unique. Therefore, they argue, the original animation should be preserved to maintain the historical authenticity and to respect the vision and craftsmanship of the original creators.

In conclusion, while the idea of remaking Star Trek: The Animated Series with modern CGI could potentially enhance the visual quality and bring the series into the modern era, many fans believe that preserving the original animation is paramount. The series’ nostalgia, the legacy of its creators, and the historical context of the original work all contribute to its enduring appeal and should be respected as part of the Star Trek canon.