Sherlock: A Critical Analysis of Mistakes and Consistencies in the Series

Introduction

The BBC series Sherlock, which aired from 2010 to 2017, is generally well-regarded for its unique approach to the Sherlock Holmes mythos and engaging storytelling. Despite its critical acclaim, the series is not without its share of inconsistencies and mistakes that have been noted by fans. This analysis aims to delve into these issues, providing a detailed breakdown of continuity errors, character inconsistencies, plot holes, technical mistakes, and historical inaccuracies.

Continuity Errors

Continuity errors are perhaps the most noticeable mistakes in the series, often distracting from the overall viewing experience. One prominent example is the inconsistency in the age of the character Connie Prince. In the episode “The Great Game” of Season 1, the TV in the diner is seen displaying the headline: “Make-over Queen Connie Prince dead at 48.” However, when Detective Lestrade enters the room, his statement clearly states that Connie Prince was 54. This discrepancy showcases a minor but notable mistake in the series.

Character Inconsistencies

A significant aspect of the series is the character consistency of Sherlock Holmes, but this too has its challenges. The emotional responses and social interactions of Sherlock occasionally shift, making it feel inconsistent with his established personality. This inconsistency can be particularly jarring for viewers who have come to know and love Sherlock's character traits. For example, in later seasons, Sherlock's social interactions and emotional responses sometimes deviate from his established personas, leading to a sense of dissonance for viewers.

Plot Holes

Several fans have pointed out plot holes in the series, especially in the later seasons. One example of a plot hole is the resolution of the Moriarty subplot in Season 4, which many fans found unsatisfying. The teased return of Moriarty in the end of Season 3 built a significant amount of excitement, only to be ultimately resolved in a way that left many viewers feeling underwhelmed.

Technical Mistakes

Technical mistakes throughout the series have also been noted. One such example is in Season 2, where Sherlock follows John Holmes as he meets a mysterious woman. Sherlock receives and understands a text message, but when Mrs. Hudson is later held at gunpoint, it is unclear why Sherlock would be holding onto John's phone. This inconsistency, while perhaps unnecessary for the plot, can still be notable for die-hard fans who value technical accuracy.

Historical Inaccuracies

While the show is set in modern London, it does not always stick to historical accuracy. For instance, some adaptations of classic stories or historical references have been noted as being either inaccurate or overly dramatized. This can be particularly disappointing for those looking to see a more faithful representation of the original characters and settings.

Critical Reception of Season 4

Season 4 onwards received mixed reviews from both critics and fans. While the first three seasons were widely praised, Season 4 was often described as disappointing. One fan review succinctly summarizes this sentiment, stating that the fourth series was 'unwatchable dross,' with an unfulfilling resolution to the highly anticipated return of Moriarty.

Closing Thoughts

Despite these issues, many fans still appreciate Sherlock for its unique take on the Sherlock Holmes mythos and its engaging storytelling. While the series is not without its flaws, it remains a beloved and critically acclaimed work that continues to attract both new and old fans.