Introduction

Sam Tarly's complex emotional journey in response to the tragic deaths of his father, Randyll Tarly, and brother, Dickon Tarly, at the hands of Daenerys Targaryen is deeply rooted in his character development in both the Game of Thrones books and the HBO series. As a character who grapples with his sense of duty, loyalty, and the implications of violence, Sam's reactions are multifaceted and often filled with conflicting emotions.

Shock and Grief

Sam Tarly is known for his deep connections to his family, despite his strained relationship with his father. The sudden and violent loss of his father and brother would likely elicit a strong emotional response from Sam, marked by profound shock and grief. This reaction stems from the deep roots of familial bonds in Kristrov and the personal tragedy that has befallen his closest ties.

Anger and Betrayal

The news of his family's deaths by Daenerys might also stir feelings of betrayal within Sam. If he had previously viewed Daenerys as a potential ally in the fight against the Night King and the White Walkers, this turning of the blades would complicate his perspective on her quest for the Iron Throne. Daenerys's betrayal would heighten these emotions, leading Sam to question her intentions and actions.

Conflict of Loyalty

Sam's sense of duty and loyalty, especially to Jon Snow, would likely create inner turmoil for him. The tragic deaths of his family members could exacerbate his conflict between his allegiance to Jon (who he sees as a protector) and the implications of Daenerys's actions. This internal conflict would be a central theme in Sam's emotional state.

Desire for Justice

Sam might also seek some form of justice or retribution in response to his family's deaths. This desire would be driven by his processing of grief and anger, and may compel him to confront Daenerys or take action against her. This act of seeking justice would be a manifestation of his deep-seated sense of right and wrong.

Reflection on Legacy

The tragedy would also provoke Sam to reflect on the meaning of his family's legacy, particularly in relation to his own identity and future. Having already struggled with his sense of worth and belonging, the deaths of his father and brother might deepen these existential questions. This introspection would be a crucial moment in Sam's character growth.

Personal Choices and Hypocrisy

Sam's actions in the aftermath of this tragedy raise questions about his consistency and morality. He chose to drop the bomb on Jon, revealing the deaths of his family, in an attempt to satisfy his own need for vengeance, while simultaneously adhering to a code of honor that sees betrayal as a grave offense. This action highlights his hypocrisy, as he expected the same moral code from Jon while disregarding it himself.

Sam's desire for justice against his family's betrayers, Randyll and Dickon, is juxtaposed with his acceptance of the unjust fate of other individuals. Robb Catelyn, Talisa Maester, and the Stark retainers, who were less deserving of death, were not afforded the same treatment from Sam. This discrepancy in his views and actions further cements his image as a hypocrite, a self-promoting and vindictive character.

Ultimately, Sam's reaction to the death of his father and brother is a reflection of his complicated nature, deeply influenced by his sense of duty, loyalty, and the moral ambiguities prevalent in the world of Game of Thrones.