Robert Baratheon and his Bastard Sons: A Severe Aftermath?

In the complex and often dark world of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire, King Robert Baratheon’s legacy is constantly under threat. The revelation that Joffrey and Tommen were illegitimate could have sent ripples through his reign, but what would Robert’s reaction have been?

Given the historical context and Robert’s character, he would likely have been deeply affected by such a discovery, given his strong emphasis on his lineage and legacy. However, his actions would have been driven more by political survival than by the moral high ground.

Political Maneuvering Over Sentimental Loyalty

Instead of sending Joffrey and Tommen to the Night’s Watch (Nights Watch), Robert would more probably have sought to secure his political machine. The Night’s Watch traditionally serves as a penultimate resort for individuals with no other options; they would be more likely to support such a decision than to see these young lords sent into exile or worse. His priority would have been to protect his throne and ensure the legitimacy of his rule, not to send his supposed heirs to an uncertain fate.

Immediate Risks and Reactions

The gravity of the situation would not have been lost on Robert. The betrayal of his twin children by their incestuous parents would have been met with immediate and severe consequences. The incestuous relationship would be seen as deeply taboo in Westeros, and their enemies would see this as an opportunity to eliminate them. The Night’s Watch, while a potential refuge, would not have been the safest option.

Public and Private Reactions

Robert’s probable blind rage at the discovery would have led to immediate harsh actions. Ned Stark, knowing Robert well, recognized the immediate danger these children posed. His desire for Cersei to escape to Essos, despite him being the second most powerful man in Westeros, was driven more by a need to protect her and the children than by any hope of divine safety.

The Fate of All Involved

Considering the severe consequences, it is likely that Joffrey, Tommen, their parents Jaime and Cersei, would all have faced dire fates - almost certainly death. Their illegitimate status and incestuous parentage would make them abominations in the eyes of many, and religious zealots would certainly demand their elimination. The threat they posed to the stability of the realm would not have been overlooked, even in the face of Ned Stark’s protests.

Conclusion

In summary, while it is an interesting scenario to consider, Robert’s actions would have leaned more towards political maneuvering to protect his legacy and secure his rule, rather than sending his sons to the Night’s Watch. The involvement of the Night’s Watch would have been a last resort, and even then, it would have been more about eliminating the threat than providing refuge.