Review of True Detective Season 2 Episode 1: The Western Book of the Dead

As a seasoned exploratory analyser of television series, I find myself diving into the intricate web of plot and character development of True Detective Season 2. Specifically, Episode 1, titled 'The Western Book of the Dead', presents an interesting contrast to its esteemed predecessor, offering a unique blend of mystery and intrigue. Here is my take on the episode and what it implies for the rest of the season.

Season 2's Contrast to Season 1: A Shadow of Lesser Glory

Based on the first episode, it's clear that Season 2 doesn't quite live up to the heights of Season 1. Nevertheless, the promise of a compelling story lingers. As for the murder of Ben Casper, the case remains a mystery, much like the shadows that linger in the story of True Detective. Furthermore, the absence of Rust Cohle looms large, leaving a void that no character can quite fill.

Character Analysis

Season 2 introduces some incredibly complex characters, but they are also strikingly articulate. However, my interaction with them has been less than favorable thus far. Although some characters might evolve with the season, I'm not holding my breath for change.

Ray Velcoro: A cop who moonlights for a crime boss, Ray is more than just a character with a tragic past. His actions and decisions are as morally grey as the cases he uncovers, making him a fascinating study. Yet, his methods are not without question. An instance of his brutality toward a suburban dad whose son bullied his child is a stark reminder of his flaws. Paul Woodrugh: Also known as Woodruff, he has a tortured soul from his war experiences. Despite his vulnerability, he's not entirely unlikeable. However, his pitiful state as a character makes it hard to fully engage with him. His actions and psychological state are deeply layered, offering much to unpack during the season. Ani Bezzerides: Initially, I was excited to see a female character who could hold her own beside the men of Season 1. However, her internal struggles and the nonsensical reasons for a bust on an adult film shoot are overwhelming. Her actions, such as leading the operation based on an unsubstantiated rumor that also backfired, reveal a character who sees flaws in herself and others. Frank Semyon: So far, he is the most rational of the lot, hinting at a potential reclamation of character. However, his status as a crime boss creates a moral dilemma that might undermine his potential likeability.

Plot Analysis and Speculation

The mystery around the mutilated corpse of the corrupt city manager is a promising lead. However, the ambiguity and multiple jurisdictions add to the complexity of the case, enhancing its overall intrigue. Instead of straightforward crime-solving, the episode presents a murky landscape where every detail, even seemingly insignificant ones, becomes a potential red herring.

Specifically, the skeleton found in the city manager's house hints at dark, perhaps occult, activities. While it might be a straightforward Halloween decoration, the atmospheric implications are significant. This suggests that the story weaves through the supernatural and the mundane, making every detail worth noting.

Questions and Speculations

Where has Ray's ex-wife gone, and who is the man who picked up the child from school? The mention of Ray potentially killing the individual who attacked his ex-wife casts a dark shadow over his character.

The character of Ani's father and the subplot of the missing woman—a strong woman in her right—merit attention. This could be more than mere plot device; it might offer deeper insights into Ani's background and motivations.

Even the resemblance between Paul's girlfriend and a missing woman adds another layer to the mystery. Is there a connection?

In conclusion, True Detective Season 2, while presenting a shadow of less glory compared to its predecessor, continues to weave a rich, complex narrative. The characters are deep, the plot is intricate, and the atmosphere is haunting, making this season a compelling watch. While the initial episodes offer a glimpse of muscle and mystery, the full story of Season 2 awaits further unraveling.