Review of The Mummy and The Mummy Returns: A Geographic Analysis

Have you ever found yourself navigating the broader timeline of The Mummy and The Mummy Returns? These movies, while beloved by some, often leave viewers questioning the logical consistency of their ancient characters. In this article, we delve into the geographical and historical contexts of these films, offering a critical analysis of their narrative and characters.

Introduction to The Mummy

Firstly, let us examine the original 1999 film, "The Mummy." Although it is not considered a masterpiece, it remains an enjoyable choice for those who enjoy classic action films. Beni, the cowardly yet sympathetic protagonist, serves as an intriguing character whose motivations and actions often leave one questioning his morality.

A notable character in the film, Bernard Fox, plays a World War One veteran pilot who is tragically buried alive. His death scene, coming after his desire to be buried alive, adds a layer of complexity to his character and prompts discussions on the physical limits and moral choices of the characters.

The Challenges of The Mummy

The Egyptian guards in "The Mummy" may be among the most flawed characters in the franchise. Their decision to use the Homdai as a punishment is a catastrophic blunder, leading to the potential resurrection of the evil mummy, Imhotep. This act of revenge ultimately dooms the world to Imhotep's tyranny, showcasing the consequences of arrogance and hubris.

The sequence where Ardeth Bay, a well-meaning protagonist, stops a fight upon seeing a dynamite stick, reveals the futility of ancient weapons against modern technology. This decision highlights the clash between different eras and the limitations of prehistoric and modern warfare.

Continuity Concerns in The Mummy Returns

Transitioning to the sequel, "The Mummy Returns" (2001), the film faces significant challenges in maintaining continuity and character development. The reincarnation of Anck Su Namun, a complex character from the original, becomes an arbitrary and illogical plot device. The inconsistency in her timeline and the introduction of her son, who becomes an annoying sidekick, further detract from the film's quality.

The scenes involving the scarab beetles, while amusing, serve little purpose in advancing the plot and add more confusion to the already complex narrative. The bizarre reincarnation of Anck Su Namun from a mummy to a human becomes a logical leap that diminishes the original's subtle depth.

Amusing Gameplay in Sequals

Despite the film's shortcomings, there are a couple of scenes that manage to amuse the audience. The secondary villains' curiosity about curses and the midget mummy graveyard scenes add a touch of humor, albeit unintentional. The presence of Dwayne Johnson as the Scorpion King, while made famous in a later production, feels misplaced and less engaging than the original actors in "The Mummy."

Conclusion

In conclusion, while "The Mummy" offers a more entertaining and logically consistent plot, "The Mummy Returns" lacks the depth and continuity necessary to stand the test of time. For those looking for a nostalgic trip through the early 2000s, "The Mummy" remains a fine choice, but "The Mummy Returns" should be avoided if you seek a more profound cinematic experience.