Introduction to the Stargirl Dilemma

The Arrowverse, a rich network of interconnected DC superhero shows, recently introduced a new Stargirl alongside its existing character in Legends of Tomorrow. This introduction has sparked a debate among fans and critics, questioning whether the writers are intentionally avoiding continuity or simply making creative choices. Let’s delve into the nuances of this situation and clarify some common misconceptions.

Character Introduction in Different Earths

The new Stargirl was originally part of the DC Universe streaming service, with shows like Titans, Doom Patrol, and Swamp Thing. However, CW took over the broadcast rights for Stargirl and Swamp Thing, causing an alignment issue. To resolve this complexity, the writers divided the Stargirl characters between two different Earths in the multiverse.

In Legends of Tomorrow, Stargirl is a member of the 1950s Justice Society, existing on pre-crisis Earth 1. The new Stargirl series takes place on post-crisis Earth 2. This decision ensures that the characters are distinct and relatable to their respective series. The pre-crisis Stargirl is played by Patricia Arquette, while the post-crisis Stargirl, now played by Brec Bassinger, is a different character in a different timeline.

Continuity and Multiverse Theory in the Arrowverse

Some fans argue that the Arrowverse writers are simply forgetting or ignoring past introductions, citing Legends of Tomorrow’s Stargirl. However, this overlooks the complex nature of the multiverse. The Arrowverse operates under a different multiverse theory, where events can unfold differently in alternate timelines. The older Stargirl character from Legends of Tomorrow is part of Earth-Prime, where the multiverse was intact.

The new Stargirl in the series reflects a different timeline where the multiverse concept has changed. In this context, her stories can coexist without conflicting with the established Arrowverse continuity. The key point is that the writers are not forgetting or ignoring past characters but are crafting unique narratives for each series to maintain a cohesive yet diverse universe.

Continuity Issues in the DC Universe

Continuity issues are a hallmark of the DC Universe, particularly within the Arrowverse. The Arrowverse, like other adaptations of the DC franchise, often plays fast and loose with continuity to ensure creative flexibility. This was evident in the Flash series, where Grant Gustin and Ezra Miller’s Speedster characters were distinct and not part of the same multiverse.

DC’s approach to continuity is challenging for viewers who crave a consistent universe. However, for the writers, it allows them to explore different storylines and characters without the constraints of a rigid timeline. This approach has both benefits and drawbacks. On one hand, it encourages fresh storytelling and exploration of different Earths. On the other hand, it can be confusing for fans who are glued to the continuity.

Marvel and DC Continuity

In comparison to DC, Marvel has faced its share of continuity issues as well. For instance, the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. attempting to crossover with the MCU was met with similar complications due to the involvement of different companies. Marvel resolved this issue by recasting actors and adjusting storylines, enabling a more seamless experience.

Both DC and Marvel have their methods for handling continuity. DC tends to embrace complexity and explore different Earths and timelines, while Marvel often strives for cross-media cohesion. These differences reflect the distinct histories and goals of each universe. Ultimately, the choice of how to handle continuity is a creative decision that impacts viewer experience.

Conclusion

The introduction of the new Stargirl in the Arrowverse is not a matter of forgetting or ignoring past characters but a creative choice to maintain a diverse and interconnected multiverse. While continuity can be a challenge in the complex world of DC, the writers have attempted to craft a universe that encourages exploration and story diversity.