Narcissa Malfoys Allegiance if Married to Sirius or James: A Deep Dive into Character Alignment
Narcissa Malfoy's Allegiance if Married to Sirius or James: A Deep Dive into Character Alignment
Narcissa Malfoy, born into a pureblood family, embodies the ideals of Lucius and the Slytherin house: intense prejudice against muggles and muggle-borns. Her allegiance to Lord Voldemort and the belief in pure-blood superiority is rooted deeply, making it highly unlikely that she would support the Order of the Phoenix, even if she were to marry either Sirius Black or James Potter.
Background and Character Background
As a member of the Black family, Narcissa’s views were heavily influenced by her upbringing. Her interactions with muggles and muggle-borns were influenced by the disdain and contempt taught by her parents, Orion and Walburga Black. In the novel, this is evident during her shopping trip with Draco in Madam Malkin’s shop, where her actions reflect the disdain typical of her family’s beliefs.
Despite her family’s background, Narcissa only switched her allegiance when her son’s safety was at risk. This underscores the lengths she would go to protect her family, even if it meant aligning with Voldemort and his regime. Her actions during her marriage to Lucius Malfoy align with this perspective, where personal loyalty and family safety are paramount.
Assumptions and Scenarios
If Narcissa were to marry either Sirius Black or James Potter, two key characters from the Order of the Phoenix, several scenarios can be imagined:
1. Suitable Personality Fit or Forced Marriage
Given that Narcissa would not naturally align with their values, two primary reasons for a marriage would be a completely different personality or a forced marriage. In a forced marriage scenario, her family’s disapproval would be a significant factor, leading to complex familial and personal dynamics.
2. If Narcissa Had a Neutral Personality
Assuming Narcissa developed a neutral personality and fell in love with a younger man such as James Potter, several possibilities arise. Her parents, despite the contradiction between their budding relationship and her family’s values, would likely be conflicted. On one hand, Narcissa would marry into significant wealth, aligning with the family’s desire for financial security. On the other hand, James’s support of muggle rights and peace would go against her upbringing.
Typically, Narcissa would be faced with three choices: denounce her family and face potential disownment, stay resentfully loyal to James, or betray James to stay with her birth family. The complexity of these choices indicates the intense pressure she would experience, ultimately leading to her prioritizing her family and her son's safety over her personal values.
3. Forced Marriage to Sirius Black
In a forced arranged marriage with Sirius Black, who is also aligned with the Order, Narcissa might initially be torn. The Black family tradition emphasizes blood purity, and if Sirius were part of the Order, she might initially align with him. However, the loss of Sirius to Voldemort would create a significant loss, making her free to marry again. In this scenario, the conflict between her family and her loyalty to Sirius would likely lead to betrayal and information-gathering aligned with her family and Voldemort.
Conclusion
No matter the outcome, Narcissa Malfoy’s alignment would ultimately be driven by her love for her family and her son. Her actions would reflect her deep-seated commitment to protecting them, even if it meant aligning with Lord Voldemort and the Death Eaters.