The Misattribution of "Judy Judy Judy": A Hollywood Legend

The phrase 'Judy Judy Judy' has become a catchphrase in popular culture, often erroneously attributed to actors from classic Hollywood films. This article explores the true origin of the phrase and its impact on comedy and cinema.

Origin of the Line

The phrase 'Judy Judy Judy' is not actually a line from a film but originates from a nightclub act. In the 1950s, comedian Larry Storch was doing an impersonation of actor Cary Grant in a nightclub. Suddenly, Judy Garland walked into the room. Displeased at being interrupted, Larry Storch shouted in his Cary Grant impersonation, 'Judy Judy Judy, you can't do this to me!' The line was so hilarious that it quickly became a staple of the nightclub act.

Popular Misattribution in Hollywood

Though the line originated in a nightclub act, it has often been misattributed to actors and actresses in films. Specifically, it has been falsely associated with the character Cary Grant. In reality, Cary Grant never uttered this line as it was part of Larry Storch's act, imitating Grant's voice. This misunderstanding has led to many comedic skits and impersonations, including Rich Little’s act.

Rich Little, an American comedian and voice impersonator, has used the phrase 'I have a duty duty duty to Judy Judy Judy,' mimicking Cary Grant’s impersonation. This further cemented the phrase in the public imagination, even though it was never spoken by the original actor.

Classic Film Appearance

While Cary Grant did not say 'Judy Judy Judy,' he did appear in a film where the name Judy was prominently featured. In the 1939 film 'Only Angels Have Wings,' a line is spoken that closely resembles the phrase:

'Judy, my dear girl…'

Grant’s character uses the name 'Judy' in a tender manner, but the famous catchphrase is not part of this dialogue. Nevertheless, this line has often been mistaken for the misattributed phrase.

The film 'Only Angels Have Wings' is a classic of the era, directed by Howard Hawks, and stars Cary Grant as the lead character. While Grant's character does not say 'Judy Judy Judy,' the line has become so ingrained in popular culture that many people believe he did.

Conclusion

The line 'Judy Judy Judy' has a rich history in comedy and impersonation, but it is important to note its true origin. Larry Storch's nightclub act, imitating Cary Grant, was the source of the phrase, not a scene in a film. Despite this, the phrase continues to be referenced in comedy and popular culture, highlighting the power of misattribution in keeping certain lines or jokes alive.