Is Star Trek Discovery a Reboot or a New Chapter of Trek? Debunking the Myth

Recently, after the mid-season finale of Star Trek Discovery, the show has garnered both praise and criticism. Some viewers argue that it doesn't fully fit into the Star Trek universe, while others see it as a fresh start. So, is Star Trek Discovery a reboot or just a new chapter in a rich cosmic saga? Let's explore the evidence.

Claim: Is Star Trek Discovery a Reboot?

The term 'reboot' often brings to mind a complete overhaul of a beloved franchise, where new characters and storylines replace the old ones. However, Star Trek Discovery doesn't quite match this definition. The show's creators and producers have been clear about this fact.

Key Points from the Producers

Star Trek: Discovery producer and writer Akiva Goldsman has stated, 'We are not the Kelvin timeline... which is a reboot of the original timeline... We are not part of that timeline. We are the original timeline with the TV shows and the movies that fit into that. We are ten years before The Original Series... Where Constitution Class ships are in comparison to where this Discovery prototype – well one of two prototypes – are technologically is obviously a variant. We are wildly aware of everything that appears to be a deviation from canon. We will close out each of those issues before we arrive at the 10-year period and hit TOS.'

Furthermore, Star Trek: Discovery writer Aaron Harberts has emphasized, 'The audience just has to be patient because typically if it seems like we’re violating canon we know. We know that people might have knee-jerk reactions to things. But we have a plan.' Another producer added, 'In terms of canon, we want to make sure that all of that stuff tracks. So whatever you pull up in Picard’s computer needs to be correct by the time we end our run.'

Character and Setting Differences

Star Trek Discovery features a different lineup of characters and a new setting compared to the original series. The producers and writers have often cited that the show is set before the original series. They emphasize that while some elements may seem out of place, they are part of a larger continuity.

Many claim that the show's plot points, such as the Spore Drive, introduce elements that could be considered from an 'alternate universe' or a new reality. For example, in a recent episode, Captain Lorca used the Spore Drive to map time and space, and his willingness to take a final 'jump' to sector 133 might suggest he knew the risks and was seeking an escape or return to his original universe.

Alternatives: Visualizing a Continuity

One way to reconcile the differences is to visualize how a modernized Original Series might look. Imagine a more intense, fast-paced show that better fits today's society. This approach can make Star Trek Discovery, albeit different, still feel like a part of the Star Trek universe.

Producer Ted Sullivan noted, 'Enterprise did a lot of scrambling and covering and patching up things which I think worked for that show. It is hard to be in the middle between that show and TOS. Kirsten Beyer will probably tell you the most arguments she and I have had are me saying "Wait we can't do that because of something on Enterprise." But we respect that. Enterprise is canon and it's tough and it was a constantly shifting show.'

Conclusion: Star Trek Discovery is a New Chapter, Not a Reboot

In conclusion, despite some elements that may seem jarring or out of place, Star Trek Discovery is not a reboot. It is a new chapter in the ongoing saga of Star Trek. The show's creators have been deliberate in maintaining a connection to the greater Star Trek continuity. Whether you enjoy it or not, it represents a significant and thought-provoking addition to the Star Trek universe.