Is Piper Chapman Morally Good? A Comprehensive Analysis

The character of Piper Chapman in the television series Orange Is the New Black presents a complex moral portrait that invites viewers to engage deeply with the ethical nuances of her actions. This article explores Piper's character from both objective and subjective perspectives to provide a nuanced understanding of her morality.

Objective Analysis of Piper Chapman

Piper Chapman, the protagonist of Orange Is the New Black, is often seen as a morally complex character. Her actions can be evaluated in terms of their adherence to moral principles and the consequences they bring. Here are some of the key morally questionable actions she has taken:

Beating Pennsatucky

In the first season finale, Piper defends herself against Pennsatucky, a fellow inmate. However, the line between self-defense and aggression is blurred when Piper continues to beat Pennsatucky, even when she is clearly overpowered. This act can be seen as morally unjustifiable, as it goes beyond what is reasonably necessary for self-defense.

Being Mean to Soso

Piper's treatment of Soso, a new inmate, demonstrates a lack of compassion and empathy. Instead of welcoming Soso, Piper mocks her and acts condescendingly. This behavior highlights Piper's self-centeredness and lack of awareness of others' feelings, making her actions morally blameworthy.

Not Recognizing Her Privilege

Piper frequently complains about her struggles, showcasing a lack of awareness of her own privilege. Her failure to recognize her advantages in life contributes to her self-righteous attitude, which can be seen as morally negative.

Putting Alex in Prison for Stella

Piper's decision to rat out Alex to Stella and put her back in prison shows a clear lack of moral judgment. Piper's actions are motivated by a desire for revenge and a need for attention, indicating a morally compromised decision-making process.

Panty Business and Race Issues

Piper's business ventures, particularly the online panty business and the subsequent racism issue, highlight her obliviousness to the consequences of her actions. Her actions in this scenario demonstrate a significant lack of moral empathy and ethical responsibility.

Subjective Analysis of Piper Chapman

While Piper's actions are open to moral scrutiny, her subjective motivations and character development offer a more nuanced understanding. Here are some insights into Piper's subjective take:

Motivations for Actions

Piper's actions are often driven by a desire for purpose and validation. She takes actions to feel as if she has made a difference or to satisfy her emotional needs. For example, reopening the running track and installing kickball.

Her quote illustrating her struggles: 'I brought this on myself. This is what I’ve become… How do I come back from this? I sent Stella down the hill. Why did I do that? My parents didn’t teach me to be like this. What I did to Maria… I didn’t feel bad. I didn’t think twice. I just went too far. I always go too far. I always go too fucking far. And I can’t fucking stop it. I think that I’ve been trying to win prison.'

This quote encapsulates her moral quandary and the recurring nature of her mistakes. Piper’s immaturity and lack of self-awareness add depth to her character, making her both relatable and morally complex.

Conclusion

Whether Piper Chapman is morally good depends on one's perspective. While her actions often reflect morally questionable decisions, her character development and motivations provide a balanced view. Piper's journey reveals the complexities of moral judgment and the constant struggle to make ethical choices in a challenging environment.

Top 10 of the Worst Things Piper Has Done

1. Beating Pennsatucky

2. Being mean to Soso

3. Not recognizing her privilege

4. Putting Alex in prison for Stella

5. Panty business and race issues

6. Cheating on Anissa

7. Lying to Nenni about her relationship with Nicky

8. Giving up her job to the least qualified candidate

9. Saying goodbye to Lea without closure

10. Failing to support convicted pilferer Janine's mental wellbeing

These actions shed light on the moral challenges faced by Piper Chapman.

What Makes Actions Morally Good

Morally good actions are those that promote the well-being of others and adhere to ethical principles. Actions that minimize harm, demonstrate empathy, and foster respect and justice are generally considered morally sound.

Final Thoughts

Evaluating the morality of Piper Chapman involves a balance between objective scrutiny and subjective understanding. Her character, rich with nuance and complexity, invites viewers to reflect on the moral implications of their own actions.