Inconsistencies and Flaws in 'Tombstone': A Critical Analysis

While 'Tombstone' (1993) remains a beloved classic, particularly for Western movie enthusiasts, it's not without its fair share of inconsistencies and flaws. Below, I'll delve into some of the narrative slip-ups and character actions that have puzzled viewers over the years, followed by a tribute to the film's strengths.

The Big Missteps in 'Tombstone'

1. Doc's Unexpected Appearance:

One of the most glaring inconsistencies in the film is the appearance of Doc Holliday at the site of the final showdown between Wyatt Earp and Johnny Ringo. In the movie, Wyatt has to ask a cowboy where Ringo is, but Doc appears exactly where Ringo is waiting, seemingly without looking for it. How did Doc know where to go? This scene is a prime example of a plot hole that detracts from the film's overall narrative consistency.

2. The Gunfight in Town:

Another issue is the presence of guns within a supposedly no-gun town. Both Doc Holliday and Johnny Ringo carry firearms during an important dialogue scene, defying the rule that guns are forbidden in town. Neither character is deputized at that time, and this conflict of rules undermines the film's built-in coherence and logic.

The Heroic Performances and Perfect Structure

Despite these inconsistencies, 'Tombstone' is undeniably a captivating and visually stunning film. The performances by the actors are nothing short of spectacular, and the entire movie benefits from an inspiring blend of dialogue, cinematography, and music. Let's take a closer look at why 'Tombstone' remains a cherished Western classic.

3. Michael Biehn's Johnny Ringo:

Michael Biehn delivers a captivating performance as Johnny Ringo that stands as one of the greatest of his career. His portrayal is nuanced and intense, fully capturing the complexities of Ringo's character. The actor's ability to convey the drifter's emotional turmoil and his decision to participate in the final showdown is a testament to Biehn's talent.

4. Powers Boothe's Curly:

Powers Boothe brings a mesmerizing performance as Curly, contributing greatly to the film's authenticity and depth. His charisma and commanding presence are a fitting match for the demanding role of Curly.

5. Stephen Lang's Ike Clanton:

Stephen Lang's portrayal of Ike Clanton is nothing short of a masterclass in acting. His brilliant performance steals the show, embodying the complexity and fearlessness of the character. Lang's portrayal is a highlight that elevates 'Tombstone' to new heights of excellence.

Other Must-Loved Elements

The supporting cast, including Val Kilmer as Doc Holliday and Kurt Russell as Wyatt Earp, also delivers strong performances that are memorable and full of depth.

6. Cinematography by William A. Fraker:

The film's cinematography is outstanding, capturing the desolate and harsh landscapes that define the Old West. The visuals enhance the story and atmosphere, making each scene feel authentic and vivid.

7. Musical Score by Bruce Broughton:

Broughton's score is not just background music but an integral part of the film's emotional journey. The music adds depth and emotion, contributing to the film's overall impact.

Finding Perfection in Imperfection

While 'Tombstone' is far from perfect, its consistent strengths vastly outweigh its minor flaws. The film is a perfect example of how a few small inconsistencies can be overlooked when the performances, direction, and overall quality of the production are so high. 'Tombstone' stands as a testament to the genre and a reminder that even the best films are not without their imperfections.

Spoilers Ahead:

The most significant flaw in 'Tombstone' that has bothered many viewers for years is the role of Michael Rooker's character, whose absence and the mangled corpse viewers encounter later are connected. This revelation, which only became clear through multiple viewings, is a significant plot hole that affects the film's narrative integrity. However, despite this oversight, Rooker's character's disappearance and reappearance are vastly outweighed by the film's stellar performances and thematic depth.

If you haven't seen 'Tombstone' yet, it's highly recommended. Trust me, once you watch it, you'll understand why it has become a beloved classic in the Western genre.