Imagining a 2017 Remake of Star Wars Prequels: Perfecting the Cast and Script

If the Star Wars prequels were to be remade for release in 2017, would the same cast be the best choice? The allure of such an endeavor lies in reimagining the battles, the characters, and bringing the stories to a contemporary audience. While the current cast is indeed a treasure trove of talent, certain adjustments could enhance the series significantly. Let's explore who the ideal cast might be and how the script could be perfected to make the prequels a true masterpiece.

A Closer Look at the Current Cast

Many purists would maintain that the original cast should remain untouched, citing their exceptional performances and the chemistry they brought to the series. However, limited recasting can help address certain aspects that could be improved upon. One that would likely remain unchanged is the late Elijah Wood, whose portrayal of Frodo Baggins is indeed a testament to his talent. Nevertheless, other roles might benefit from fresh perspectives.

The Case for Refreshed Talent

The prequels owe much of their quality to the dialogue and the delivery of the lines. While reading the lines on the page can be impressive, translating them into spoken words is another level of challenge. This is where a ballsiest script doctor and a competent director come into play. It's crucial to have someone who can tell George Lucas when the dialogue is not working. As one article poignant suggests, an early intervention might have saved many cringe-worthy moments.

Elements such as:

Realistic dialogue that doesn't sound like it came directly from a marketing brochure Character development that feels authentic and relatable A core script that avoids overcomplication and remains focused

These are just a few areas where adjustments could make a significant difference.

Staff Recommendations for Cast and Direction

For the ideal 2017 remake, the cast and director should align seamlessly to create a compelling narrative. Here are some recommendations that could breathe new life into the prequels:

For Obi-Wan Kenobi: Rupert Friend, with his profound acting range, could bring a nuanced and complex portrayal of the wise and wary Jedi.
For Leia Organa: Emma Watson, known for her grace and fiery spirit, could revitalize the portrayal of Princess Leia, bringing out a softer, more complex side of the character.
For Anakin Skywalker: A younger actor like Alden Ehrenreich or Miles Teller could captivate audiences with fresh energy and a more plausible narrative progression.
For Gandalf/Elections (if any): Eddie Murphy, with his unique wit and broad range, could bring humor and charisma to the table, making any scenes he appears in truly memorable.

With these actors, the prequels could benefit greatly from a more grounded and relatable storyline. Directors like J.J. Abrams or even Marcus Dunstan (known for his work in various horror and action genres) could bring a fresh and dynamic approach to filmmaking, ensuring that the visual and narrative aspects are top-notch.

Conclusion: Moving Forward

While the cast remains a cornerstone of the Star Wars prequels, it is crucial to emphasize the importance of a robust script and competent direction. A combination of the right actors and a capable team can transform the prequels from a gratuitous homage to a gripping and engaging narrative. By modernizing the dialogue, refining the character arcs, and ensuring that the stories are told with emotional depth and authenticity, the Star Wars prequels could emerge as a beloved and long-lasting franchise.