If P.T. Barnum Could See 'The Greatest Showman', What Would He Think?

When we watch 'The Greatest Showman', a modern interpretation of the life of P.T. Barnum, one can't help but wonder what the real person behind the name would think of it. Would he appreciate the embellishments and romanticized narrative, or does he merely see a misrepresentation of his life?

The Sights and Sounds of The Greatest Showman

One thing is for certain: P.T. Barnum would likely have enjoyed the way the film presents the show. The colorful costumes, dazzling performances, and uplifting songs would captivate even the most cynical of showmen. He wouldn’t mind the embellishments that were added to the plot; they would, in fact, enrich the story.

The movie itself is a richly intelligent and entertaining piece of work, a combination of colorful musicals and beautiful cinematography. The songs in the film have become iconic, capturing the spirit of the circus and the showman's life. These energetic and memorable tunes would undoubtedly resonate with Barnum, giving him a sense of pride and a nod to his legacy.

Promoting Diversity and Success: A Modern Barnum

However, there is a stark difference between the historical P.T. Barnum and the one portrayed in the film. While the movie portrays him as a handsome hero, promoting diversity and camaraderie, the real P.T. Barnum was not at all the same. He was, indeed, just 'in it for the money,' and his legacy as a showman was more about profit than principle.

According to Barnum, the idea of promoting diversity was a marketing tool, not a genuine belief. In fact, his motives were primarily commercial, and he would be quick to use any means necessary to draw a crowd and make a profit. This contrast highlights the difference between the romanticized Hollywood version and the real-life figure.

Historical Accuracy vs. Artistic License

Despite the historical inaccuracies, one can't help but appreciate the artistic license taken by the filmmakers. As much as Barnum would love the movie for its sense of grandeur and the joy it brings, we, as film enthusiasts, understand that the movie is not meant to be a documentary. It’s a piece of art, a story told from a contemporary perspective, and should be appreciated as such.

It’s important to remember that filmmakers are working within the context of their time and must make creative choices to engage and inspire modern audiences. Therefore, the film’s inaccuracies, while they may disappoint history enthusiasts, are a justified means to create an engaging and inspiring narrative.

A Perfect Blend of Modern and Historical

The film strikes a balance between history and imagination, something Barnum himself might have appreciated. While it may not be a faithful representation of his life, it captures the essence of the spirit of showmanship that was central to his career. This blend of elements is a testament to the enduring appeal of P.T. Barnum’s legacy.

Moreover, the film’s ability to make the audience feel entertained and inspired by P.T. Barnum’s ingenuity and the magic of the circus would likely find favor with him. The movie perfectly encapsulates the dream of a grand spectacle and the transformative power of entertainment.

Final Thoughts

While it is true that The Greatest Showman is not a historically accurate portrayal of P.T. Barnum, it does offer a compelling and entertaining glimpse into the world of a charismatic showman. As an admirer of Barnum’s legacy, I understand that the film is a work of art that should be judged on its merits as a piece of entertainment and a tribute to the spirit of showmanship.

For more in-depth analyses and reviews of films, visit my blog: Film Reviews with Ethan J.