Harry Potter and the Motherly Mistakes: A Speculation on Professor McGonagall vs. the Dursleys

If the infamous Albus Dumbledore had not intervened, would Professor Minerva McGonagall have taken Harry Potter under her wing? While it might seem ideal to some, this speculative scenario raises many questions and uncertainties. Let's explore the possibilities and the impact such a decision could have had on Harry's life.

Professor McGonagall vs. the Dursleys: A Stern Comparison

One of the key differences between Professor McGonagall and the Dursleys in terms of raising Harry would be the level of care and love. Professor McGonagall, known for her sternness and strict sense of morality, would have raised Harry with a strong moral character and a love for learning and truth. In contrast, the Dursleys were more focused on keeping Harry from accessing his magical capabilities and providing him with a minimal existence.

Harry’s Missed Opportunities

Had Professor McGonagall raised Harry, the young wizard might have missed out on some of his magical milestones that were introduced by Hagrid. For instance, Harry’s love for beasts and his interactions with Acromantula could have been fostered in a more nurturing environment. The spiders, particularly in the case of Aragog, could have become a powerful ally to Harry in his final battle at Hogwarts. His admiration and respect for Aragog and other creatures could have been even stronger, as he bonded with them from an early age.

Moreover, the death of the Basilisk within the Chamber of Secrets might have been celebrated differently, as Professor McGonagall would have understood and appreciated Harry’s bravery and contribution to the school's safety. The memories and stories of this victory might have woven a more positive and heroic narrative for Harry, enhancing his character and self-esteem.

The Impact on Harry’s Personality

Professor McGonagall’s more structured and academically oriented approach to parenting might have shaped Harry into a more disciplined and intelligence-driven individual. While Hagrid brought the rough and wild aspects of the wizarding world to Harry, Professor McGonagall would have provided a more stable and supportive environment. This could have made Harry even more reverent towards Dumbledore, as he would have grown up understanding the importance of order and law in the wizarding world.

Practical Challenges and Dumbledore’s Interference

Although Professor McGonagall might have been a better caregiver than the Dursleys, the practical challenges of raising Harry would have been significant. Quitting her job and moving away from her duties would have been necessary but would also have caused personal and professional upheaval. Additionally, Dumbledore would have eventually found out about her decision. His interference was a significant factor in the Dursleys’ guardianship, and this dimension might have influenced him to find a way to make Professor McGonagall relent and return the custody of Harry to the Dursleys.

However, there are scenarios, like the one described in the fanon story “Harry McGonagall,” where Professor McGonagall defies Dumbledore and takes Harry, then hands him over to her nephew. Despite its flaws, this scenario highlights the complexities and potential heartaches that such a decision could have entailed. The story is not without its tropes but does offer a glimpse into the moral dilemmas faced by characters in the Harry Potter world.

The “Short List” of Possible Adoptive Parents

Considering the history and relationships in the Harry Potter universe, other wizarding families would have been the natural fit for raising Harry. Dumbledore’s comments hint at “plenty of wizarding families” that would have gladly taken Harry in. It is reasonable to assume that the Weasley family, known for their loyalty and sympathies towards the Order of the Phoenix, would have been among the top choices. The Weasleys, admired for their warmth and family values, would have provided a loving and supportive home for Harry, further advancing the Order’s goals and creating a stronger bond with Harry and his parents.

In conclusion, while the idea of Professor McGonagall raising Harry might seem ideal for some, the complexities and challenges of such a decision highlight the unintended consequences and the intricate balancing act that Dumbledore and other key characters had to navigate throughout Harry’s life.