Exploring the Similarities Between Classic and New Doctor Who

Since the revival of the Doctor Who series in 2005, fans and scholars have often debated which period of the show is most reminiscent of the classic era. While the new series undoubtedly brings a modern twist, certain segments can resonate with fans of the original show. In this article, we delve into the nuances of the similarity, examining key periods of both classic and new Doctor Who.

Similarities in the Graham Williams Years

One of the most striking similarities can be found in the Graham Williams years, specifically in seasons 16 and 17 of the Fourth Doctor, and in the core UNIT era with the Third Doctor for seasons 7 and 8. These periods are characterized by a balance of humor and adventure, akin to the new series.

Seasons 16 and 17 of the Fourth Doctor are filled with fast-paced action and witty dialogue, which can appeal to fans of the modern show. The core UNIT era with the Third Doctor, while set in the 1960s, tells stories that have a timeless quality. These narratives still involve complex moral dilemmas, engaging mysteries, and heartfelt connections, which are reminiscent of the new series.

The Last Season and a Half of the Classic Series

The final season and a half of the original Doctor Who series, from 1988 to 1989, offers perhaps the most direct comparison. This period revolves around the story of a companion, Ace, and her relationship with the Doctor. The show delves deeply into her backstory, making it a more human and relatable character.

Ross Martin, Ace, and the Doctor embark on an emotional journey to understand who she is and her future. This theme of mentorship and the cultivation of a strong connection between the Doctor and the companion echoes the new series. Additionally, the show acknowledges the Doctor’s mystery and invites viewers to question him, a feature that Steven Moffat would expand on in the new series.

The New Series#39; Influences and Predecessors

Another point of comparison lies in the structure and pacing of the new series. Much of the innovative content that viewers now enjoy was hinted at in various elements of the original show. For instance, the use of a companion romance, as seen in the TV movie, and the more modern pacing and special effects, were present in the 1996 era.

Specifically, the TV movie of 1996 previewed elements that became hallmark features of the new series, including romantic tension, embraced humor, and enhanced visual effects. The structure of the new series is reminiscent of the old-fashioned episodic format but with a more contemporary twist, blending the best of both worlds.

The Wilderness Era and Its Evolution

The wilderness era, which began right after the cancellation of the original show, saw the development of companions' arcs, relationships, and even time travel ideas in novels and audio stories. Significant works such as Scream of the Shalka from 2003 offer a fascinating insight into how the series might have evolved with a classic approach.

Big Finish's audio range, spanning from 2008 to the present, further demonstrates how the classic style of storytelling can adapt to modern sensibilities. These stories not only maintain the charm of the classic era but also incorporate new, engaging narratives that appeal to contemporary viewers. The Eighth Doctor stories, in particular, showcase a blend of classical and modern storytelling techniques.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the new Doctor Who series is undoubtedly modern in its approach, certain elements and periods of the classic show align closely with its style and content. The Graham Williams years, the last season and a half of the original series, the innovative TV movie, and the evolving companion arcs all provide instances where the new series echoes themes and storytelling techniques found in the classic era.

By understanding these similarities, fans can appreciate the continuity and evolution of this beloved franchise, recognizing that the new series builds upon the strengths of the classic show while infusing it with innovative modern sensibilities.