The Critical Reactions to The Force Awakens

The release of The Force Awakens in 2015 sparked a wave of critical reactions, with many viewers and critics pointing out various criticisms and plot holes. This article explores the main points of contention and evaluates these through a lens of both criticism and supporting arguments.

Criticism: Plot Too Similar to A New Hope

One of the most common criticisms is that the plot of The Force Awakens is too similar to or a direct remake of A New Hope. Many viewers felt that the story felt overly familiar and predictable. The hero's journey, with Rey's arrival at the Hidden Jedi Temple, the corruption of the hero-leader, and the unfolding narrative, all seemed to echo the original trilogy's storyline.

Criticism: Rey as a Mary Sue

The character of Rey has been a source of controversy in the critical discourse. Some critics argued that Rey is a Mary Sue, a term often used to describe a fictional character who is overly perfect and well-equipped, making them nearly invincible. Rey's abilities, charisma, and background have been scrutinized, with many questioning whether she is too overwhelmingly powerful to be a relatable character.

Criticism: Lack of Political Context

The film has also been criticized for lacking political context. Many viewers felt that the political environment and power dynamics in the new galaxy were not well-explained. The absence of political intrigue and subtext, compared to the depth and complexity found in the prequel trilogy, left some feeling unsatisfied and confused.

Criticism: Coincidences and Contrivances

The movie heavily relies on coincidences and contrivances, which some critics argue detract from the integrity of the narrative. For example, the timing of Finn's arrival and escape in the Millennium Falcon at the end of the film seems too convenient. Critics argue that these plot elements feel tacked on rather than organic to the story.

Criticism: Safety and Predictability

Similarly, some argue that the film took no risks and played it too safe, resulting in a predictable and formulaic narrative. The highly anticipated moments, such as Rey's connection to Luke Skywalker, feel underwhelming and overly reliant on established tropes rather than delivering fresh and unique storytelling.

Criticism: Rushed Execution

Another point of criticism is the rushed execution of major events, which leaves significant plot points unexplored and unresolved. Scenes that could have provided deeper insight into the characters and the world were glossed over, leading to a sense of hurried storytelling.

In conclusion, while The Force Awakens was widely successful and beloved by many, it is also the subject of significant scrutiny and criticism. The film's adherence to familiar tropes, the potentially one-dimensional portrayal of its characters, and the lack of political context have all been points of contention. However, these criticisms can also provide valuable insights for future storytelling and expansion of the Star Wars universe.