Critical Analysis: Snyder Cut vs Original Justice League - Is it Better or Worse?

The Snyder Cut of Zack Snyder's Justice League was released in 2021, hailed for its improvements over the original 2017 Justice League. However, while praised for its depth and character development, the film arguably falls short in several critical areas. This article will explore how the Snyder Cut might be considered worse than its predecessor in terms of pacing, character development, tone, visual effects, narrative cohesion, and audience fatigue.

Pacing Issues

One of the most significant differences between the Snyder Cut and the original Justice League is the run time. The Snyder Cut clocks in at around four hours, making it nearly double the length of the original version (about two hours). While this extended film provides a denser cinematic experience with more plot points and character development, it can also be overwhelming for viewers. The longer runtime often leads to pacing issues, making the narrative feel drawn out and less engaging. This can be particularly evident in moments where the film drags, detracting from the overall immersive experience.

Character Development

The Snyder Cut takes a deep dive into character backgrounds, providing a richer and more nuanced understanding of characters like Cyborg, Aquaman, and Shazam. However, it also introduces new characters and subplots, such as the previously non-existent Barry Allen and his role as the Flash, that some viewers find unnecessary and confusing. These additions can detract from the cohesion of the main storyline, potentially alienating audiences unfamiliar with the broader DC universe. While these elements contribute to a more comprehensive character study, they may also lead to a fragmented narrative experience for some viewers.

Tone and Accessibility

The darker tone of the Snyder Cut may not be to every viewer's taste. While many fans appreciate the serious, gritty atmosphere, it might alienate those who preferred the lighter, more humorous tone of the original cut. The original Justice League aimed to appeal to a broader audience by blending action with humor, making it more accessible and enjoyable for a wider demographic. The darker tone can be seen as more appealing to die-hard fans, but it risks losing the casual viewer who might be put off by the intense narrative and tone.

Visual Effects

Some visual effects in the Snyder Cut receive criticism for not being as polished as those in the original. The extended production time allowed for some sequences to be perfected, but others might still fall short of the high standards set by the film's hype. This inconsistency can affect the overall viewing experience, with some visuals appearing less refined compared to the polished post-production of the original cut.

Narrative Cohesion

The Snyder Cut attempts to provide a more cohesive narrative, layering in numerous subplots and character arcs. While this approach can enrich the film, it may also lead to a less focused overall story. The original cut had a more streamlined plot, which allowed for a more clear and engaging narrative. The multiple storylines in the Snyder Cut might confuse or bore some viewers, detracting from the clarity and coherence of the main plot.

Audience Fatigue

Given its length and density, the Snyder Cut might contribute to audience fatigue. Some viewers might find the extended runtime and dense narrative overwhelming, especially for a superhero film. A more concise storytelling approach is often preferred, as it allows viewers to follow the plot with less strain and keeps the viewing experience more enjoyable. The original Justice League, with its two-hour runtime, strikes a balance between providing sufficient depth and maintaining viewer interest throughout.

Conclusion

While the Snyder Cut is generally seen as an improvement in terms of character depth and narrative complexity, these improvements may detract from its overall appeal compared to the original Justice League. The film's pacing, tone, and character development may not resonate with all viewers, and the narrative and visual effects might not meet the expectations set by the hype surrounding it. Ultimately, the choice between the Snyder Cut and the original cut comes down to personal preference and viewing style.