Can a Person Defeat a Dragon Like Smaug with Enough Preparation and Resources?

The idea of defeating a dragon, specifically Smaug, has long captivated the imaginations of many. This piece delves into the feasibility of such a feat, exploring potential strategies and the high costs involved. We will also examine the vulnerabilities of these mighty creatures and the ethical dimensions of proposed tactics.

The Ethical Dilemma of Bombur's Last Meal

One of the most radical – and ethically questionable – strategies that comes to mind involves a strategy reminiscent of “Bombur’s last meal.” This involves a few dwarves being fatally poisoned, perhaps with a highly potent toxin like cyanide or even polonium radiation, to ensure a slow and painful death. The dwarves would be distributed the poison two days before the planned attack, ensuring the toxin is well-distributed throughout their bodies. The plan would then revolve around luring the dragon into consuming one of the poisoned dwarves. Once ingested, the dragon’s internal organs would begin to fail, gradually weakening the massive creature.

This method is highly unethical and morally reprehensible. However, given the desperate circumstances that dwellers of Lonely Mountain must face, one can understand the willingness of dwarves to employ such measures. The survival of their precious horde often becomes the priority over the welfare of a single individual, even if that individual is deemed expendable for the greater good.

The Vulnerabilities of Dragons

While the idea of poisoning a dwarf might seem innovative, it’s important to consider the broader context of dragon weaknesses. Unlike the great, fire-breathing, winged dragons, the dragons mentioned in earlier tales have significant vulnerabilities, especially in their stomach regions. A notable example of a successful dragon defeat involved a special sword made from a meteorite, known for its ability to cut through nearly anything. This blade was wielded by one of the top three human warriors in history, a feat that could not easily be replicated by others, even with extensive preparation and resources.

Take Turin, for instance, a skilled warrior. Even he failed in his attempt without the meteorite sword. It highlights the importance of not only physical strength but also unique and often unpredictable advantages. Modern dwarves, lacking access to such extraordinary tools, are left with unconventional yet still desperate tactics.

Challenges in Defeating Winged Dragons

Winged dragons, particularly the more formidable varieties, present a distinct set of challenges. Their hides are impervious to arrows and lethal enough to melt the mighty Rings of Power. Their fire can remove oxygen from large areas, as evidenced by Smaug’s deadly tactics that led to the asphyxiation of many dwarves. Despite the efforts of even elite archers and warriors, traditional methods such as arrows and swords prove insufficient against these creatures.

As such, the idea of poisoning a dwarf through a concentrated and potent toxin remains one of the few strategies with a realistic chance of success. The key lies in ensuring that the dragon is lured into consuming the poisoned dwarf. It is a gamble fraught with peril and moral quandaries, but it may offer the last chance for survival.

Conclusion: The Ethical and Practical Consequences

In the end, the idea of defeating a dragon like Smaug through conventional means is nearly impossible. Unconventional strategies such as “Bombur’s last meal” introduce significant ethical dilemmas. While such tactics may seem cold and calculating, they highlight the desperate measures taken in times of extreme peril. The most practical approach, at the moment, involves leveraging any unique tools or resources that might offer a glimmer of hope against these ancient and fearsome creatures.