Can Two Beholders Peacefully Coexist Without Mutual Destruction?

In the realm of Dungeons and Dragons (DnD), beholders are often depicted as xenophobic creatures that view every other beholder as an abomination, leading to automatic hostility and combat upon encounter. However, the concept of peaceful coexistence between beholders presents an intriguing challenge that defies this established lore. This article explores the feasibility of such harmony through various roles and options, ultimately highlighting the power of the Dungeon Master (DM) in shaping in-game outcomes.

Option 1: The Love Potion Solution

The most whimsical solution to a beholder standoff involves a love potion. In this scenario: Both beholders would consume a love potion. Both beholders would fail their saving throws (assuming a Charisma DC 13 for 5th edition). The beholders would then see each other as the first sentient creature they encounter after taking the potion. This results in adoration and a 1-hour period where they must obey any commands given to them by this creature.

Option 2: Aligned Helmets of Opposite Alignment

This method attempts to neutralize the innate hostility through a change in alignment. The steps are as follows: Place a helmet of opposite alignment on each beholder. Ensure that both beholders fail their saving throws, switching their alignment from Lawful Evil to Chaotic Good. Provide extensive therapy and counseling to help them recognize the validity and respect the other beholder.

Option 3: Dominating Two Beholders

Utilizing Dominant Monster and Permanency spells can create a cooperative pair of beholders: Cast Dominant Monster on both beholders. Have both beholders fail their saving throws. Order them to tolerate each other and refrain from attacking. Follow with a Permanency spell to ensure the effect lasts indefinitely.

Option 4: The Forgotten Realms Influence

For players and DMs operating in the Forgotten Realms setting, a hive mother can take matters into her own tentacles and ensure dominance among the beholders: Invoke a hive mother to control both beholders.

Option 5: Aboleth Intervention

An even simpler solution involves using an aboleth, which can both begin and end the conflict with ease. No Forgotten Realms setting is necessary for this method: Use an aboleth to either initiate or resolve the situation.

The Ultimate Option: DM Authority

Ultimately, the power of the DM cannot be overstated. Here’s how the process might unfold: The DM conjures two beholders who are destined to work together. The party encounters the first beholder, leading to conflict. As the battle ensues, the second beholder appears to the party. With glee, the DM watches as the party collectively confronts the challenge of cooperating with a beholder.

Conclusion

The question of whether two beholders can peacefully coexist without mutual destruction hinges on the DM’s creative vision and the rules they choose to enforce. Whether through love potions, aligned helmets, domination, or Divine intervention, the power of the DM allows for flexibility and innovation in gameplay. These options present a thrilling challenge for players, adding depth and unpredictability to their DnD adventure.