Is There an Element of Snobbery Over Book vs Movie?

Often, discussions about the superiority of books over movies or vice versa are accompanied by a subtle or not-so-subtle form of snobbery. This article aims to explore whether such snobbery exists and if it is ever justified. We will also delve into the reasons why people often have a preference for enjoying both mediums.

Perception of Snobbery

The assertion that book readers are somehow more intelligent than those who only watch the movie can indeed be seen as a form of snobbery. However, this perception often stems from the belief that reading a book requires a deeper level of engagement and mental effort. From a practical standpoint, enjoying a movie does not necessarily require less intelligence; it simply demands a different form of engagement—such as visual and auditory experiences.

No Book to Read

What if there is no book to read? In such cases, there is no basis for snobbery. Enjoying a film can be a valuable and enriching experience regardless of the absence of a literary counterpart. This idea is crucial because it challenges the notion that a movie can only be appreciated if it is based on a book. While some movies are indeed adaptations of books, many original scripts offer compelling stories and unique experiences that stand on their own.

Snobbery in Comparison

It is important to acknowledge that discussing any form of media, whether it be books or movies, often involves comparing and contrasting them. This comparison is not inherently negative; it is simply a natural part of human nature to evaluate and judge different forms of entertainment. The issue arises when this comparison leads to snobbery or when one form of media is somehow deemed inferior to the other.

Examples of Comparison

One example of a comparison that often results in snobbery is the adaptation of Jaws. The book, by Peter Benchley, offers a different level of detail and description, which can enhance the reader's experience. However, the movie, directed by Steven Spielberg, provides a more streamlined and action-packed narrative, which is perhaps more accessible to a wider audience. The book's ending, in the original adaptation, is altered in the movie, which some purists may find less satisfying. Nevertheless, the movie remains a classic and a thrilling piece of work in its own right.

The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings trilogy provides a fascinating case study. J.R.R. Tolkien's books are rich with detail, history, and mythology, making them a substantial read. Peter Jackson's films, while undoubtedly altering and condensing the narrative, still capture the essence of the story. Critics often argue that the movies are too long, but they also highlight that reading the books is a prerequisite for full enjoyment. This suggests that the book is seen as a more comprehensive and detailed experience, while the movie offers a more concise synopsis.

Modern Learning Styles

Today, individuals have different learning styles and preferences. Some may prefer to read a book, while others find movies more engaging. The idea that book readers are inherently more intelligent is a subjective claim that lacks concrete evidence. Intelligence comes in various forms, and the ability to absorb and enjoy a story through different mediums does not necessarily define a person's intellectual capabilities. Many intelligent individuals, such as yourself, may prefer to learn through videos or other visual formats.

Movie Appreciation without Book Background

Enjoying a movie does not mean one cannot appreciate the nuances and depth of a book. Many movies, like The Lost Cities of Paraguay, The Mission, The Natural, Schindler’s List, Apollo 13, Saving Private Ryan, and Rocky, offer exceptional visual and auditory experiences that enhance the storytelling. The music in these movies, composed by masters like Ennio Morricone, contributes significantly to the overall experience, making it difficult to replicate the same level of emotional impact in a book.

Conclusion: Embrace Both

Ultimately, the debate between books and movies is largely personal. There is no inherent superiority or inferiority to either medium. The key is to embrace both and enjoy them for what they offer. Whether you prefer the depth and detail of a book or the immediacy and visual storytelling of a movie, both have their unique strengths and value.