Why Does Benjen Stark Remind Jon Snow He's Not a Ranger?

Benjen Stark's unfaltering belief in the importance of experience is a recurring theme throughout A Song of Ice and Fire series, particularly in the interactions between Jon Snow and his uncle. As Jon focuses on proving himself as a leader and desiring to take on the mantle of a ranger, Benjen emphasizes the foundational aspects of his training and character development. This essay delves into the nuances of their relationship and the wisdom behind Benjen's advice.

Jon Snow's Holistic Character

Jon Snow is a complex character, a teenage boy filled with angst and a desire to transcend his initial perceptions of success. He is not just a fighter but a commander, a young man with the weight of expectations from a world that values family and tradition over mere prowess. At the Wall, Jon's understanding of success is skewed, focusing on individual achievement over collective duty. He believes that one can succeed based on who their father is, rather than their own actions and attitude. This is a misconception that Benjen must rectify.

Journey of Self-Discovery

Benjen's efforts to instill humility and a realistic perspective in Jon are akin to a parent's role in shaping a teenager's worldview. Jon’s initial pride and impatience to prove himself are natural sentiments, but they obscure a deeper truth. His favorite hero, Aemon the Dragonknight, further underscores Jon's wish for epic heroism and missing out on his destined role.

The True Message Under the Surface

Benjen's statement goes beyond simple advice; it might have been a more profound one – not just that Jon is not a ranger, but that he is a king. Jon's arrival at the Wall is a turning point, mirroring his arrival at the castle where he was born. Just like a teenager with a car key, he is eager and impatient but lacks the necessary wisdom and experience. Benjen sees something more in Jon—a potential leader, a king, but one who must first build the foundation.

The Role of Uncle Benjen

Uncle Benjen serves as a mentor and a guardian, urging Jon to accept the entry-level tasks as a crucial part of his development. In essence, Benjen is not just teaching Jon about military strategies and ranger duties but also about humility, responsibility, and the importance of starting at the bottom. Jon's frustration stems from the realization that he cannot gain experience without facing challenges, which is a lesson all teenagers must learn.

Interpreting Benjen's Message

Benjen's warning to Jon that he is not a ranger challenges Jon's notions of heroism and success. Jon wants to be seen as a hero, not a follower, and this desire often blinds him to the importance of preparation and perseverance. Benjen knows that Jon's journey will be long and difficult, filled with challenges and setbacks. This is where Jon must start – with the basics, and only then can he grow into the formidable leader he hopes to become.

The Significance of Benjen's Counsel

Benjen's approach to Jon’s development is both wise and necessary. Modern psychology supports the idea that teenagers need guidance and limits to shape their character and prepare them for the real world. Jon's uncle serves as a critical figure in providing this guidance, much like a parent setting boundaries and expectations. By emphasizing the importance of foundational experiences, Benjen ensures that Jon does not rush into situations unprepared, risking danger for himself and his companions.

The revelation that Benjen sees a future for Jon as a great ranger and even a king underscores the depth of his mentorship. Benjen’s belief in Jon’s potential fuels his determination to prepare Jon for his destiny while also remembering that the journey is just as important as the destination. By starting with the simpler tasks, Jon can develop the skills, instincts, and character needed to face the challenges ahead.