Benjen Stark as Coldhands: Exploring the Possibilities of George R.R. Martin’s Hidden Story

The mystery surrounding both Benjen Stark and Coldhands in George R.R. Martin's epic A Song of Ice and Fire series continues to intrigue fans. While GRRM himself has dismissed the theory, many speculate that Benjen Stark is, in fact, Coldhands. This article delves into the evidence and theories supporting this belief, thoroughly examining the characters' backgrounds and interactions within the story.

A Speculation on Benjen's Fate

Based on what we've seen in the television adaptation of A Song of Ice and Fire, it is likely that Benjen Stark's fate aligns with Coldhands' mysterious demise. The show portrayed a brief and intense encounter with the Others, leading to Benjen's untimely death. However, the Children of the Forest intervened, using dragon glass to plunge through his heart, staving off his ultimate demise and preserving him as an Undead Good Kind of Wight. This unexpected twist ties into a larger narrative that suggests Benjen Stark is indeed Coldhands, albeit in a resurrected form.

Contradictory Evidence: GRRM's Manuscript Notes

One of the key criticisms of the theory is GRRM's response in his original manuscript. In a hidden note in the margins, one of his editors questioned whether Coldhands was Benjen Stark, to which GRRM emphatically wrote a clear NO. Although this response is widely accepted, it may not be the final word. Since GRRM is known for his intricate storytelling and unexpected twists, many argue that the official position might not be as straightforward as initially thought.

Bran's Encounter with Coldhands

Bran's interactions with characters in the show, particularly Coldhands, raise a significant point. When Bran inquires about Coldhands to Leaf, the Children of the Forest, she mentions that the White Walkers had already killed him long ago. The phrase long ago is vague and open to interpretation, allowing for a wide range of potential meanings. It could refer to a few days, months, or even years, all of which support the theory that Benjen Stark's identity as Coldhands has deeper implications.

The Case for Ser Waymar Royce

An alternative theory proposes that Ser Waymar Royce is the true identity behind Coldhands. Waymar Royce's heroic but tragic end as a White Walker turns wight adds a layer of complexity. In the original novels, GRRM mentioned that Ser Waymar was killed by the Others in the prologue to A Game of Thrones. However, his father's strength, noble lineage, and the runic armor hint at a deeper magic. Some argue that GRRM might have intended for Ser Waymar to be resurrected as Coldhands through the use of children of the forest magic, maintaining his identity while protecting his noble house.

Additional Evidence Supporting the Theory

The Stark connections are noteworthy. Both Benjen Stark and Coldhands share the Stark bloodline, making it plausible that they are the same individual. The identity of Coldhands as a Stark aligns with the overarching themes of honor, duty, and nature in the series. Additionally, the idea that a Stark could be resurrected and wield the forces of nature resonates with the dark and complex world created by GRRM.

Conclusion

While GRRM's official stance seems to dismiss the idea, the evidence supporting the theory that Benjen Stark is Coldhands is intriguing. From the layers of mystery surrounding both characters to the historical context and magical elements, the possibility remains open for this fascinating twist to be revealed in the future. The question of who Coldhands is continues to captivate fans, and until GRRM provides further confirmation, the identity of Benjen Stark as Coldhands remains a tantalizing speculation.

References

GRRM (George R.R. Martin)'s original manuscript and editor notes. John's observation of long ago in Bran's conversation with Leaf. The history and characteristics of House Royce and Coldhands. The role of the Children of the Forest and dragon glass in the story.

Image Credits

For reference, the image proving that Ashara Dayne was at the Tower of Joy.