Understanding the Merrow’s Harpoon in Dungeons Dragons 5e

Introduction

The Merrow's harpoon is an intriguing weapon used by monsters with a 4 Strength and 0 Dexterity. This weapon, with its listed damage of 2d64, presents a unique challenge for game balance. Typically, weapon damage in Dungeons Dragons 5e is optimized based on the character's abilities. The Merrow's harpoon, however, stands out due to its nature as both a range and melee weapon.

Weapon Analysis

The damage of 2d64 implies that the weapon is strength-based, given the low Dexterity score of the user. This feature may make sense in the context of melee combat but appears unusual for a ranged weapon. One might argue that the double damage dice could be a character trait rather than an inherent feature of the weapon itself. Therefore, the base damage might actually be 1d6.

Game Balance Considerations

There are two main possibilities for balancing the Merrow's harpoon. It could be considered a larger weapon like a trident or a unique weapon with its own set of characteristics. Here are two configurations:

Merrow Harpoon Trident

5 gp 1d6 piercing damage (thrown) 20/60 versatile 1d8 Martial Melee Weapon

Merrow Harpoon Unique

10 gp 2d6 piercing damage (thrown) 20/60 heavy two-handed Exotic Melee Weapon Special Merrow’s pull feature

Gameplay Decisions

The Merrow's harpoon can be quite powerful, depending on how one rules its balance. If it is treated as a larger trident, players will have a familiar weapon to handle. However, if it is a unique weapon, it will necessitate a range check to ensure proficiency does not overly hinder its use.

Using it as the Merrow does, it would likely not benefit from a proficiency bonus due to its nature as a unique weapon. This rule would make sense, as it adds an element of challenge and unique gameplay.

Conclusion

The Merrow's harpoon presents a unique opportunity for game balance in Dungeons Dragons 5e. Whether it is a larger trident or a unique weapon, the damage and versatility of the harpoon make it a powerful and intriguing choice for players and dungeon masters alike.