Analyzing George Lucas's Reservations about The Last Jedi: A Closer Look into Star Wars Evolution

After the release of The Force Awakens, I found myself reflecting on the film and the expectations it would set for the subsequent installment. My thoughts were simple: 'It was a fun, fan-service driven rehash of the original trilogy, but the next film must take a bold and unconventional direction.' And so, we entered the era of The Last Jedi.

Flaws and Pioneering Ideas

While The Last Jedi has its share of flaws, it did step away from the comfort zone and attempt several new and ambitious ideas. Some, like the introduction of a new lightsaber igniting scene for Luke Skywalker, were well-received despite the initial misunderstanding. Others, such as the portrayal of Rey, were met with criticism, with many dismissing her character as hastily thrown together. However, the film ultimately aimed to challenge expectations and create a new hero who could arise from any background, not just being born to legendary Jedi.

Directed with Vision and Innovation

Rian Johnson, the director, embraced a new direction by introducing dynamic female characters like General Milu and emphasizing the potential of Rey's abilities. Despite these characters not being fully fleshed out, they signified a step toward creating a more inclusive and diverse universe. The ending of the film suggested a shift in the storytelling, moving away from the 'special singular ones' and hinting at group heroism, which was a significant departure from the franchise's established formula.

The Reception and Its Impact

Undoubtedly, the overwhelming desire for comfort and familiarity in the form of fan service led to a mixed reception for The Last Jedi. Some viewers came in expecting the predictable and rehashed content, but were instead confronted with a more complex and challenging narrative. The film’s attempt to push boundaries and innovate was both praised and criticized, with many believing it to be unnecessary and off-putting.

Lucas's Uncertainty and the Star Wars Continuum

George Lucas's uncertainty regarding The Last Jedi is understandable given the complexity of the project and its divergence from the established canon. The film stands as a bridge between the prequel trilogy and the new Star Wars era, bringing in new ideas and characters that question the very essence of the franchise. In this context, it is crucial to recognize the film within the broader narrative of Star Wars evolution, acknowledging both its limitations and its groundbreaking moments.

Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords, for instance, offered a deeply nuanced take on the Force and its role in the universe, which, despite its misunderstanding at the time, remains a significant entry in the Star Wars canon. Similarly, The Last Jedi can be seen as an ambitious experiment, one that, while not universally embraced, contributes to the richness and diversity of the Star Wars saga.

In conclusion, The Last Jedi is a testament to the ongoing evolution of the Star Wars universe. While it may not appeal to everyone due to its innovative and sometimes controversial approach, it is a valuable addition that challenges the status quo and paves the way for future storytelling in the franchise. The journey of Star Wars, particularly post-The Last Jedi, will undoubtedly continue to explore new avenues, reflecting the changing tastes and expectations of a constantly evolving fanbase.