An In-Depth Review of Supergirl: A Mix of Themes, Characters, and Feelings

Supergirl, the popular TV series revitalized by the Arrowverse, has been a polarizing show. It explores themes of identity, family, and social justice through its strong ensemble cast, including the titular character played by Melissa Benoist. While the series has its ups and downs, it remains an enjoyable and empowering watch for fans of superhero drama. This review delves into the multi-faceted aspects of the show, analyzing both its positive and negative points.

Exploring Aristocracy: A Theme in Supergirl

Aristocracy, an inherently peculiar concept, often manifests as an insane promoter of self-preservation and acquisition. In the context of Supergirl, this theme is embodied through the protagonist's actions and interactions with various characters and scenarios. For example, the show's portrayal of the American government, FBI, CIA, and Area 51 serve as elaborate ruses to sway the protagonist towards the acquisition of possessions, such as cigarettes, alcohol, and visual glamour, showcasing her arrogant and self-centered nature.

Supergirl’s Character Arc and Focus

Moving beyond the aristocratic pretensions, Supergirl’s character arc is at the center of the show. Her journey as a strong, yet flawed, antihero captures the attention of viewers. Melissa Benoist brings a formidable presence to the role, making the protagonist more relatable and engaging. However, her portrayal of Supergirl as arrogant and self-centered, particularly her love for attention and her tendency to prioritize her personal life over her superhero duties, has caused mixed reactions among fans.

For instance, in one episode, Supergirl is depicted as saving individuals while simultaneously killing chickens to prepare a meal for people. This sequence not only highlights the disconnection between her altruistic actions and self-serving desires but also adds to the overallumor and ridicule surrounding the character. Another aspect that receives criticism is her tendency to play with the hearts of different men, indicating her instability and lack of maturity in relationships.

Mon-El’s Impact on the Series

The introduction of Mon-El significantly enhanced the quality of Supergirl. His arrival introduced a new dimension to the series, providing more depth to Supergirl’s character and scenery. The chemistry between Supergirl and Mon-El was notable, making their storyline an enjoyable and engaging part of the show. However, the show’s decline after Mon-El’s departure is a testament to the importance of this character in maintaining the series' charm and coherence.

Mon-El’s sudden leave in the finale and the focus on his departure to the future rather than Supergirl's destiny left many viewers feeling underwhelmed. The ending of Supergirl, in general, has been criticized for lacking closure and making impactful decisions, such as delivering a satisfying resolution involving Supergirl and Mon-El.

Positive Elements of the Show

Despite its flaws, Supergirl has its merits. The series stands out in terms of its ensemble cast, compelling storylines, and exploration of serious themes. The show's crossovers with other Arrowverse series, such as Arrow and The Flash, were particularly well-received. These episodes provided high-energy, exciting content that enhanced the overall viewing experience.

Additionally, the consistency in character development and relationships, reminiscent of the beloved show Smallville, adds another layer of appreciation for dedicated fans. However, the comparison with Smallville, a show that has been celebrated as a highlight of the superhero genre, underscores the mixed feelings Supergirl evokes.

Personal Preferences and Other Series

Individual preferences plays a significant role in the perception of Supergirl. Fans of Smallville and its actors, such as Tom Welling and Erica Durance, often compare Supergirl unfavorably. The differences in tone, character chemistry, and plot development between these series contribute to a varied fan base. For instance, Tom Welling's portrayal of Clark/Superman and Erica Durance's Lois Lane is particularly cherished for their chemistry, making their absence from Supergirl a notable letdown for many.

In conclusion, Supergirl is a show with a mixed bag of themes, characters, and overall execution. While some aspects might turn off fans, the complexity of its storylines and the strong ensemble cast provide enough depth to make it an enjoyable and empowering watch. The character of Supergirl, while flawed, continues to be a source of fascination and commentary, making the series a noteworthy entry in the superhero genre.