A Balanced Review: Praise and Critiques of the TV Show Longmire

Longmire, the critically acclaimed TV show, has captured the hearts of many viewers with its compelling storytelling and rich character development. However, the show is not without its critics, particularly regarding its portrayal of Native Americans. In this article, we explore both the praises and the criticisms of the series. We will also touch upon the current landscape of the show and what fans can expect in the future.

Why Longmire Stands Out

Longmire, first aired in 2014, set in Wyoming, presents a blend of a classic Western story with modern-day complexities. The show features Sheriff Walt Longmire, played by RobertEIster, leading a sheriff's department in a small Wyoming town. This blend of old and new, nostalgia and reality, is one of the show's greatest strengths. The unique setting and the characters are diverse and layered, making for compelling and thoughtful storytelling.

Native American Representation Under Scrutiny

While Longmire has received praise for its exploration of Native American culture and history, it has also faced criticism for its portrayal. Some viewers and critics argue that the show regurgitates stereotypical and hyper-exaggerated depictions of Native Americans. The show's writers have been accused of indulging in liberal white guilt and misrepresenting Native American culture through inaccurate and simplified narratives.

For example, the use of the "habeas corpus" line was heavily criticized for its misinterpretation. The line does not mean needing a dead body to charge someone with a crime, but rather it refers to a legal right to be brought before a judge. The writers, according to some viewers, did not bother to correct this misinformation, leading to frustration and disappointment among those who value historical accuracy in entertainment.

Positive Aspects and Fan Perspectives

Despite the criticisms, Longmire has a passionate fan base who appreciate the show for its complexity and emotional depth. The characters are memorable, and the storylines are engaging. Fans appreciate the rich character development, particularly in the central characters of Walt Longmire and Henry Standing Bear, played by Wes Studi. These two characters add a layer of complexity to the narrative, representing strong and resilient Native American figures.

The fan base is also divided over romantic pairings. Some hope for a union between Cady and Branch, while others are rooting for Ferg to find love. The show's creators have maintained a balance in the relationships, keeping fans invested and engaged throughout the seasons.

Technical Aspects and Accessibility

Beyond the content, some viewers have noted issues with the show's broadcasting schedule. In the UK, for instance, Longmire is broadcast sporadically, shown on TCM via Sky. This limited availability can be frustrating for fans who cannot catch every episode in a timely manner. Nonetheless, the passionate community of Longmire enthusiasts finds ways to stay involved and discussions continue online.

Conclusion

Longmire is a nuanced and complex show that embraces the contradictions of its setting and characters. While it faces criticism for its portrayal of Native Americans, the show's strengths lie in its exploration of human emotions and its detailed character development. Fans and critics alike have found much to appreciate and discuss. Moving forward, it is hoped that the writers and creators can address these issues and provide more accurate and respectful portrayals in future seasons.

Keywords: Longmire, TV show review, Native American representation, Wyoming, Western series, character development